9. So, if some ox, or any animal you please, which is slain to mitigate and appease the
fury of the deities, were to take a man’s voice and speak these4807 words: “Is this, then, O
Jupiter, or whatever god thou art, humane or right, or should it be considered at all just,
that when another has sinned I should be killed, and that you should allow satisfaction to
be made to you with my blood, although I never did you wrong, never wittingly or unwittingly
did violence to your divinity and majesty, being, as thou knowest, a dumb creature, not de-
parting from4808 the simplicity of my nature, nor inclined to be fickle in my4809 manners?
521
Did I ever celebrate your games with too little reverence and care? did I drag forward a
dancer so that thy deity was offended? did I swear falsely by thee? did I sacrilegiously steal
your property and plunder your temples? did I uproot the most sacred groves, or pollute
and profane some hallowed places by founding private houses? What, then, is the reason
that the crime of another is atoned for with my blood, and that my life and innocence are
made to pay for wickedness with which I have nothing to do? Is it because I am a base
creature, and am not possessed of reason and wisdom, as these declare who call themselves
men, and by their ferocity make themselves beasts?4810 Did not the same nature both beget
and form me from the same beginnings? Is it not one breath of life which sways both them
and me? Do I not respire and see, and am I not affected by the other senses just as they are?
They have livers, lungs, hearts, intestines, bellies; and do not I have as many members? They
love their young, and come together to beget children; and do not I both take care to procure
offspring, and delight in it when it has been begotten? But they have reason, and utter artic-
ulate sounds; and how do they know whether I do what I do for my own reasons, and
whether that sound which I give forth is my kind of words, and is understood by us alone?
Ask piety whether it is more just that I should be slain, that I should be killed, or that man
should be pardoned and be safe from punishment for what he has done? Who formed iron
into a sword? was it not man? Who brought disaster upon races; who imposed slavery upon
nations? was it not man? Who mixed deadly draughts, and gave them to his parents,
brothers, wives, friends? was it not man? Who found out or devised so many forms of
wickedness, that they can hardly be related in ten thousand chronicles of years, or even of
days? was it not man? Is not this, then, cruel, monstrous, and savage? Does it not seem to
you, O Jupiter, unjust and barbarous that I should be killed, that I should be slain, that you
may be soothed, and the guilty find impunity? ”
It has been established that sacrifices are offered in vain for this purpose then, viz., that
the angry deities may be soothed; since reason has taught us that the gods are not angry at
4807 Lit., “in these.”
4808 Lit., “following.”
4809 Lit., “to varieties of manifold.”
4810 Lit., “leap into.”
Chapter IX.
1267
Chapter IX.