§2. Then referring to the blasphemy of Eunomius, which had been refuted by the great
Basil, where he banished the Only-begotten God to the realm of darkness, and the apology or
explanation which Eunomius puts forth for his blasphemy, he shows that his present blasphemy
is rendered by his apology worse than his previous one; and herein he very ably discourses of
the “true” and the “unapproachable” Light.
Let us also investigate this point as well,—what defence he has to offer on those matters
on which he was convicted of error by the great Basil, when he banishes the Only-begotten
God to the realm of darkness, saying, “As great as is the difference between the generate
and the ungenerate, so great is the divergence between Light and Light.” For as he has already
shown that the difference between the generate and the ungenerate is not merely one of
greater or less intensity, but that they are diametrically opposed as regards their meaning;
and since he has inferred by logical consequence from his premises that, as the difference
between the light of the Father and that of the Son corresponds to ungeneracy and generation,
we must necessarily suppose in the Son not a diminution of light, but a complete alienation
from light. For as we cannot say that generation is a modified ungeneracy, but the signific-
ation of the terms γέννησις and ἀγεννησία are absolutely contradictory and mutually ex-
clusive, so, if the same distinction is to be preserved between the Light of the Father and
that conceived as existing in the Son, it will be logically concluded that the Son is not
henceforth to be conceived as Light, as he is excluded alike from ungeneracy itself, and from
the light which accompanies that condition,—and He Who is something different from
light will evidently, by consequence, have affinity with its contrary,—since this absurdity, I
say, results from his principles, Eunomius endeavours to explain it away by dialectic artifices,
delivering himself as follows: “For we know, we know the true Light, we know Him who
created the light after the heavens and the earth, we have heard the Life and Truth Himself,
even Christ, saying to His disciples, ‘Ye are the light of the world1043,’ we have learned from
243
the blessed Paul, when he gives the title of ‘Light unapproachable1044’ to the God over all,
and by the addition defines and teaches us the transcendent superiority of His Light; and
now that we have learnt that there is so great a difference between the one Light and the
other, we shall not patiently endure so much as the mere mention of the notion that the
conception of light in either case is one and the same.” Can he be serious when he advances
such arguments in his attempts against the truth, or is he experimenting upon the dulness
of those who follow his error to see whether they can detect so childish and transparent a
fallacy, or have no sense to discern such a barefaced imposition? For I suppose that no one
is so senseless as not to perceive the juggling with equivocal terms by which Eunomius de-
ludes both himself and his admirers. The disciples, he says, were termed light, and that
1043 S. Matt. v. 14
1044 Cf. 1 Tim. vi. 16. The quotation, as S. Gregory points out, is inexact.
Then referring to the blasphemy of Eunomius, which had been refuted by the great Basil, where he banished the Only-begotten God to the realm of darkness, and the apology or explanation which Eunomius puts forth for his blasphemy, he shows that his present blasphemy is rendered by his apology worse than his previous one; and herein he very ably discourses of the “true” and the “unapproachable” Light.
463
Then referring to the blasphemy of Eunomius, which had been refuted by the…