Chapter 5.—6. I prefer, he says, to receive Christ’s baptism where both parties agree
that it exists. But those whom you intend to join say that it cannot be received there rightly;
and those who say that it can be received there rightly are the party whom you mean to
quit. What they say, therefore, whom you yourself consider of inferior authority, in oppos-
ition to what those say whom you yourself prefer, is, if not false, at any rate, to use a milder
term, at least uncertain. I entreat you, therefore, to prefer what is true to what is false, or
415
what is certain to what is uncertain. For it is not only those whom you are going to join,
but you yourself who are going to join them, that confess that what you want can be rightly
received in that body which you mean to join when you have received it elsewhere. For if
you had any doubts whether it could be rightly received there, you would also have doubts
whether you ought to make the change. If, therefore, it is doubtful whether it be not sin to
receive baptism from the party of Donatus, who can doubt but that it is certain sin not to
prefer receiving it where it is certain that it is not sin? And those who are baptized there
through ignorance, thinking that it is the true Church of Christ, are guilty of less sin in
comparison than these, though even they are wounded by the impiety of schism; nor do
they escape a grievous hurt, because others suffer even more. For when it is said to certain
men, "It shall be more tolerable for the land of Sodom in the day of judgment than for
you,"1156 it is not meant that the men of Sodom shall escape torment, but only that the
others shall be even more grievously tormented.
7. And yet this point had once, perhaps, been involved in obscurity and doubt. But
that which is a source of health to those who give heed and receive correction, is but an ag-
gravation of the sin of those who, when they are no longer suffered to be ignorant, persist
in their madness to their own destruction. For the condemnation of the party of Maximianus,
and their restoration after they had been condemned, together with those whom they had
sacrilegiously, to use the language of their own Council,1157 baptized in schism, settles the
whole question in dispute, and removes all controversy. There is no point at issue between
ourselves and those Donatists who hold communion with Primianus, which could give rise
to any doubt that the baptism of Christ may not only be retained, but even conferred by
those who are severed from the Church. For as they themselves are obliged to confess that
those whom Felicianus baptized in schism received true baptism, inasmuch as they now
acknowledge them as members of their own body, with no other baptism than that which
they received in schism; so we say that that is Christ’s baptism, even without the pale of
Catholic communion, which they confer who are cut off from that communion, inasmuch
as they had not lost it when they were cut off. And what they themselves think that they
1156 Matt. xi. 24.
1157 The Council of 310 Donatist bishops, held at Bagai in Numidia, A.D. April 24, 394. Cp. Contra. Crescon.
iii. 52, 56.
Chapter 5
705
Chapter 5