ST. ANDREWS UNIVERSITY
mistake. Mrs. Oliphant's eloquence on this subject is extremely
amusing. "We confess that all our ideas of what is life-like in
nature are suddenly confounded when we find this great and
energetic figure suddenly pause in the career thus shaped for
him, like a ship in full sail with the most favourable winds
sweeping her along upon her course, yet arrested in a moment
in mid seas, and turning aside to some little haven where only
the stress of stormswould naturally drive such a vessel. ... It is
hard to imagine how it was."
1
We may regard as a characteristic expression of the real
greatness of the man that his appreciation of relative values
differed so widely from Mrs. Oliphant's, though we may agree
that a Professorship in a University did not afford him an
appropriate sphere of usefulness. None the less, he proved an
excellent leader, and his lectures were, it is needless to say, very
eloquent and inspiring. It is also needless to say that he did
not make any important contribution to philosophy comparable
to the work of such men as Spalding or Baynes, to say nothing
of Ferrier.
It is David Ferrier who stands out as the representative of
St. Andrews Philosophy. We cannot, indeed, claim him a native
product, for he received his education in Edinburgh, Oxford, and
Germany. But the fifteen years which he spent in St. Andrews
were the fruitful years of his life. In them all his most valuable
and characteristic work was produced ; and it was produced in
immediate connexion with his activity as a teacher, the substance
of it having been given in class lectures before appearing in his
published writings. Further, his thinking was no mere derivative
stream having its primary source in other minds. He was him-
self a fountain head. In substance, the claim to originality
which he himself puts forward is justified :
"My philosophy is
Scottish to the very core ; I disclaim for it the paternity of
1 Thomas Chalmers, by Mrs. Oliphant, p. 143.
154