accept the clerical office. In fine, whatever opinion may be entertained concerning us or
concerning the people of Hippo, the case of those who may have compelled him to take the
oath is very different from that of those who may have—I do not say compelled, but at
least—counselled him to break the oath. I trust, also, that Pinianus himself will not refuse
to consider seriously whether it is worse to swear under the pressure of fear, however great,
or, in the absence of all alarm, to commit deliberate perjury.
13. God be thanked that the men of Hippo regard his promise of residence here as kept
fully, if only he come with the intention of making this town his home, and in going
whithersoever necessity may call him, go with the intention of coming back to us again. For
if they were to exact literal fulfilment of the words of the promise, it would be the duty of a
servant of God to adhere to every sentence of it rather than forswear himself. But as it would
be a crime for them so to bind any one, much more such a man as he is, so they have
themselves proved that they had no such unreasonable expectation; for on hearing that he
had gone away with the intention of returning, they expressed their satisfaction; and fidelity
to an oath requires no more than the performance of what was expected by those to whom
it was given. Let me ask, moreover, what is meant by saying that he, in giving the oath with
his own lips, mentioned the possibility of necessity preventing his fulfilment of the promise?
The truth is, that with his own lips he ordered the qualifying clause to be removed. If he put
it in, it would be when he himself spoke to the people; but if he had done so, they assuredly
would not have answered, “Thanks be unto God,” but would have renewed the protestations
which they made when it was read with the qualifying clause by the deacon. And what dif-
ference does it really make whether this plea of necessity for departing from the promise
was or was not inserted? Nothing more than we have stated above was expected from him;
but he who disappoints the known expectation of those to whom his oath is given, cannot
but be a perjured person.
14. Wherefore, let his promise be fulfilled, and let the hearts of the weak be healed, lest,
on the one hand, those who approve of it be taught by such a conspicuous example to imitate
an act of perjury, and lest, on the other hand, those who condemn it have just grounds for
saying that none of us is worthy to be believed, not only when we make promises, but even
when we give our oath. Let us especially guard against giving occasion in this to the tongues
of enemies, which are used by the great Enemy as darts wherewith to slay the weak. But God
forbid that we should expect from a man like Pinianus anything else than what the fear of
God inspires, and the superior excellence of his own piety approves. As for myself, whom
you blame for not interfering to forbid his oath, I admit that I could not bring myself to
believe that, in circumstances so disorderly and scandalous, I ought rather to allow the
church which I serve to be overthrown, than accept the deliverance which was offered to us
by such a man.
991
To Albina