Chapter
XLII.
Before we begin our reply, we have to remark that the
endeavour to show, with regard to almost any history, however true,
that it actually occurred, and to produce an intelligent conception
regarding it, is one of the most difficult undertakings that can be
attempted, and is in some instances an impossibility. For suppose
that some one were to assert that there never had been any Trojan war,
chiefly on account of the impossible narrative interwoven therewith,
about a certain Achilles being the son of a sea-goddess Thetis and of a
man Peleus, or Sarpedon being the son of Zeus, or Ascalaphus and
Ialmenus the sons of Ares, or Æneas that of Aphrodite, how should
we prove that such was the case, especially under the weight of the
fiction attached, I know not how, to the universally prevalent opinion
that there was really a war in Ilium between Greeks and Trojans?
And suppose, also, that some one disbelieved the story of Œdipus
and Jocasta, and of their two sons Eteocles and Polynices, because the
sphinx, a kind of half-virgin, was introduced into the narrative, how
should we demonstrate the reality of such a thing? And in like
manner also with the history of the Epigoni, although there is no such
marvellous event interwoven with it, or with the return of the
Heracleidæ, or countless other historical events. But he who
deals candidly with histories, and would wish to keep himself also from
being imposed upon by them, will exercise his judgment as to what
statements he will give his assent to, and what he will accept
figuratively, seeking to discover the meaning of the authors of such
inventions, and from what statements he will withhold his belief, as
having been written for the gratification of certain individuals.
And we have said this by way of anticipation respecting the whole
history related in the Gospels concerning Jesus, not as inviting men of
acuteness to a simple and unreasoning faith, but wishing to show that
there is need of candour in those who are to read, and of much
investigation, and, so to speak, of insight into the meaning of the
writers, that the object with which each event has been recorded may be
discovered.