(Thomassin, Ancienne et Nouvelle Discipline de l’Église, Tom. I. Livre II. chap 1. § iii.)
The chorepiscopi were not duly consecrated bishops, unless some bishop had consecrated
a bishop for a town and the bishop thus ordained contrary to the canons was tolerated on
condition of his submitting himself to the diocesan as though he were only a chorepiscopus.
This may be gathered from the fifty-seventh canon of Laodicea.
From this canon two conclusions may be drawn, 1st. That bishops ought not to be or-
dained for villages, and that as Chorepiscopi could only be placed in villages they could not
be bishops. 2d. That sometimes by accident a chorepiscopus might be a bishop, but only
through having been canonically lowered to that rank.
The Council of Nice furnishes another example of a bishop lowered to the rank of a
chorepiscopus in Canon viii. This canon shows that they should not have been bishops, for
two bishops could never be in a diocese, although this might accidentally be the case when
a chorepiscopus happened to be a bishop.
This is the meaning which must be given to the tenth canon of Antioch, which directs
that chorepiscopi, even if they have received episcopal orders, and have been consecrated
bishops, shall keep within the limits prescribed by the canon; that in cases of necessity, they
23
ordain the lower clergy; but that they be careful not to ordain priests or deacons, because
this power is absolutely reserved to the Diocesan. It must be added that as the council of
Antioch commands that the Diocesan without any other bishop can ordain the chorepiscopus,
the position can no longer be sustained that the chorepiscopi were bishops, such a method
of consecrating a bishop being contrary to canon xix. of the same council, moreover the
canon does not say the chorepiscopus is to be ordained, but uses the word γένεσθαι by the
bishop of the city (canon x.). The Council of Neocæsarea by referring them to the seventy
disciples (in Canon XIV.) has shown the chorepiscopi to be only priests.
But the Council of Ancyra does furnish a difficulty, for the text seems to permit
chorepiscopi to ordain priests. But the Greek text must be corrected by the ancient Latin
versions. The letter attributed to pope Nicholas, a.d. 864, must be considered a forgery since
he recognises the chorepiscopi as real bishops.
If Harmenopulus, Aristenus, Balsamon, and Zonaras seem to accord to the chorepiscopi
the power to ordain priests and deacons with the permission of the Diocesan, it is because
they are explaining the meaning and setting forth the practice of the ancient councils and
not the practice of their own times. But at all events it is past all doubt that before the seventh
century there were, by different accidents, chorepiscopi who were really bishops and that
these could, with the consent of the diocesan, ordain priests. But at the time these authors
wrote, there was not a single chorepiscopus in the entire East, as Balsamon frankly admits
in commenting on Canon xiii. of Ancyra.
75
Excursus on the Chorepiscopi.