not in the third, but in the fifth place, that ‘energy’ which follows the Only-Begotten, and
by which the Holy Spirit came into existence necessarily intervening between them.
Thereby, too, the creation of all things by the Son114 will be found to have no foundation:
another personality, prior to Him, has been invented by our neologian, to which the author-
ship of the world must be referred, because the Son Himself derives His being according to
them from that ‘energy.’ If, however, to avoid such profanities, he makes this ‘energy’ which
produced the Son into something unsubstantial, he will have to explain to us how non-being
can ‘follow’ being, and how what is not a substance can produce a substance: for, if he did
that, we shall find an unreality following God, the non-existent author of all existence, the
radically unsubstantial circumscribing a substantial nature, the operative force of creation
contained, in the last resort, in the unreal. Such is the result of the teaching of this theologian
who affirms of the Lord Artificer of heaven and earth and of all the Creation, the Word of
God Who was in the beginning, through Whom are all things, that He owes His existence
to such a baseless entity or conception as that unnameable ‘energy’ which he has just invented,
59
and that He is circumscribed by it, as by an enclosing prison of unreality. He who ‘gazes
into the unseen’ cannot see the conclusion to which his teaching tends. It is this: if this ‘en-
ergy’ of God has no real existence, and if the work that this unreality produces is also cir-
cumscribed by it, it is quite clear that we can only think of such a nature in the work, as that
which is possessed by this fancied producer of the work: in fact, that which is produced
from and is contained by an unreality can itself be conceived of as nothing else but a non-
entity. Opposites, in the nature of things, cannot be contained by opposites: such as water
by fire, life by death, light by darkness, being by non-being. But with all his excessive clev-
erness he does not see this: or else he consciously shuts his eyes to the truth.
Some necessity compels him to see a diminution in the Son, and to establish a further
advance in this direction in the case of the Holy Ghost. “It necessarily follows,” he says, “that
these energies which accompany these Beings are relatively greater and less.” This compelling
necessity in the Divine nature, which assigns a greater and a less, has not been explained to
us by Eunomius, nor as yet can we ourselves understand it. Hitherto there has prevailed
with those who accept the Gospel in its plain simplicity the belief that there is no necessity
above the Godhead to bend the Only-begotten, like a slave, to inferiority. But he quite
overlooks this belief, though it was worth some consideration; and he dogmatizes that we
must conceive of this inferiority. But this necessity of his does not stop there: it lands him
still further in blasphemy: as our examination in detail has already shewn. If, that is, the Son
was born, not from the Father, but from some unsubstantial ‘energy,’ He must be thought
of as not merely inferior to the Father, and this doctrine must end in pure Judaism. This
114 There is of course reference here to John i. 3: and Eunomius is called just below the ‘new theologian,’
with an allusion of S. John, who was called by virtue of this passage essentially ὁ θεόλογος
111
He does wrong in assuming, to account for the existence of the Only-Begotten,…