136 INSTITUTES OF THE BOOK I.
carried by those who had a greater fondness for images than
became Christians. But let us first dispose of this matter.
Those who defend the use of images appeal to that Synod
for support. But there is a refutation extant which bears
the name of Charlemagne, and which is proved by its style
to be a production of that period. It gives the opinions de
livered by the bishops who were present, and the arguments
by which they supported them. John, deputy of the East
ern Churches, said, " God created man in his own image," and thence inferred that images ought to be used. He also
thought there was a recommendation of images in the fol
lowing passage, " Show me thy face, for it is beautiful." Another, in order to prove that images ought to be placed
on altars, quoted the passage, "No man, when he hath
lighted a candle, putteth it under a bushel." Another, to show the utility of looking at images, quoted a verse of the
Psalms, " The light of thy countenance, O Lord, has shone
upon us." Another laid hold of this similitude : As the Patriarchs used the sacrifices of the Gentiles, so ought
Christians to use the images of saints instead of the idols of
the Gentiles. They also twisted to the same effect the words,
"Lord, I have loved the beauty of thy house." But the
most ingenious interpretation was the following, "As we
have heard, so also have we seen ;" therefore, God is
known not merely by the hearing of the word, but also by
the seeing of images. Bishop Theodore was equally acute :
" God," says he, " is to be admired in his saints ;" and it is
elsewhere said, " To the saints who are on earth ;" there fore this must refer to images. In short, their absurdities
are so extreme that it is painful even to quote them.
15. When they treat of adoration, great stress is laid on
the worship of Pharaoh, the staff of Joseph, and the in
scription which Jacob set up. In this last case they not
only pervert the meaning of Scripture, but quote what is
nowhere to be found. Then the passages, "Worship at
his footstool" — " Worship in his holy mountain" — " The
rulers of the people will worship before thy face," seem to them very solid and apposite proofs. Were one, with the
view of turning the defenders of images into ridicule, to