more than a quarter of the whole. Hilary was welcomed heartily and, as it would seem, un-
animously; but he had to disclaim, on behalf of the Church in Gaul, the Sabellianism of
which it was suspected, and with some reason after the Western welcome of Marcellus. He
stated his faith to the satisfaction of the Council in accordance with the Nicene confession60.
We cannot doubt that he made use of its very words, for Hilary was not the man to retreat
from the position he held, and the terms of his alliance with the school of Basil of Ancyra
required no such renunciation. The proceedings of the Council, in which Hilary took no
public part, may be omitted. The Semiarians, strong in numbers and, as they still thought,
in the Emperor’s favour, swept everything before them. They adopted the ambiguous creed
of the Council of the Dedication,—that Council which Hilary had lately called an ‘assembly
of the Saints’—for the Nicenes were a powerless minority; and they repeated their sentence
of excommunication upon the Arians, who were still fewer in number. They even ventured
to consecrate a successor to Eudoxius, one of the most extreme, for the great Church of
Antioch. Then the Council elected a commission of ten of the leaders of the majority to
present to the Emperor a report of its proceedings, and dispersed. In spite of some ominous
signs of obstinacy on the part of the Arians, and of favour towards them shown by the gov-
ernment officials, they seemed to have succeeded in establishing still more firmly the results
attained at Ancyra two years before, and to have struck another and, as they might hope, a
more effectual blow at the heretics.
But when the deputation, with whom Hilary travelled, reached Constantinople, they
found that the position was entirely different from their expectation. The intriguing party,
whose aim was to punish and displace the Semiarians, had contrived a double treason. They
xxi
misrepresented the Western Council to the Emperor as in agreement with themselves; and
they sacrificed their more honest colleagues in Arianism. They hated those who, like Basil
of Ancyra, maintained the homoiousion, the doctrine that the Son is of like nature with the
Father; the Emperor sincerely rejected the logical Arianism which said that He is of unlike
nature. They abandoned their friends in order to induce Constantius to sacrifice his old
Semiarian advisers; and proposed with success their new Homoean formula, that the Son
is ‘like the Father in all things, as Scripture says.’ His nature is not mentioned; the last words
were a concession to the scruples of the Emperor. We shall see presently that this rupture
with the consistent Arians is a matter of some importance for the dating of Hilary’s De
Trinitate; for the present we must follow the fortunes of himself and his allies. He had
journeyed with them to Constantinople. This was, apparently, a breach of the order given
him to confine himself to the diocese of Asia; but he had already been commanded to go to
Seleucia, which lay beyond those limits, and his journey to Constantinople may have been
regarded as a legitimate sequel to his former journey. In any case he was not molested, and
60 Sulp. Sev. ii. 42, iuxta ea, quæ Nicææ erant a patribus conscripta.
32
The Life and Writings of St. Hilary of Poitiers.