as though it were a kind of weapon or impregnable battlement, I sat with them for three
days in succession from morning till evening, and attempted to set them right on the subjects
propounded in the composition. Then, too, I was greatly gratified by observing the constancy
of the brethren, and their love of the truth, and their docility and intelligence, as we pro-
ceeded, in an orderly method, and in a spirit of moderation, to deal with questions, and
difficulties, and concessions. For we took care not to press, in every way and with jealous
urgency, opinions which had once been adopted, even although they might appear to be
correct.619 Neither did we evade objections alleged by others; but we endeavoured as far as
possible to keep by the subject in hand, and to establish the positions pertinent to it. Nor,
again, were we ashamed to change our opinions, if reason convinced us, and to acknowledge
the fact; but rather with a good conscience, and in all sincerity, and with open hearts620
before God, we accepted all that could be established by the demonstrations and teachings
of the Holy Scriptures. And at last the author and introducer of this doctrine, whose name
was Coracion, in the hearing of all the brethren present, made acknowledgment of his pos-
ition, and engaged to us that he would no longer hold by his opinion, nor discuss it, nor
mention it, nor teach it, as he had been completely convinced by the arguments of those
opposed to it. The rest of the brethren, also, who were present, were delighted with the
conference, and with the conciliatory spirit and the harmony exhibited by all.
3. Then, a little further on, he speaks of the Revelation of John as follows:—Now some
before our time have set aside this book, and repudiated it entirely, criticising it chapter by
chapter, and endeavouring to show it to be without either sense or reason. They have alleged
also that its title is false; for they deny that John is the author. Nay, further, they hold that
it can be no sort of revelation, because it is covered with so gross and dense a veil of ignorance.
They affirm, therefore, that none of the apostles, nor indeed any of the saints, nor any person
belonging to the Church, could be its author; but that Cerinthus,621 and the heretical sect
founded by him, and named after him the Cerinthian sect, being desirous of attaching the
authority of a great name to the fiction propounded by him, prefixed that title to the book.
For the doctrine inculcated by Cerinthus is this: that there will be an earthly reign of Christ;
619 εἱ καὶ φαίνοιντο. There is another reading, εἱ καὶ μὴ φαίνοιντο, although they might not appear to be
correct.Christophorsonus renders it: ne illis quæ fuerant ante ab ipsis decreta, si quidquam in eis veritati repugnare
videretur, mordicus adhærerent præcavebant.
620 ἡπλωμέναις ταῖς καρδίαις. Christophorsonus renders it, puris erga Deum ac simplicibis animis; Musculus
gives, cordibus ad Deum expansis; and Rufinus, patefactis cordibus. [The picture here given of a primitive synod
searching the Scriptures under such a presidency, and exhibiting such tokens of brotherly love, mutual subor-
dination (1 Pet. v. 5), and a prevailing love of the truth, is to me one of the most fascinating of patristic sketches.
One cannot but reflect upon the contrast presented in every respect by the late Council of the Vatican.]
621 This passage is given substantially by Eusebius also in book iii. c. 28.
185
From the Two Books on the Promises.