god, by that final mass in which his enemies are confined, while his own subjects are involved
in it. In fact, the principle that you call god is the more injurious of the two, both to friends
and to enemies. In the case of Hyle, there was no desire to destroy the opposite kingdom,
but only to possess it; and though some of its subjects were put to death by the violence of
others, they appeared again in other forms, so that in the alternation of life and death they
had intervals of enjoyment in their history. But your god, with all the omnipotence and
perfect excellence that you ascribe to him, dooms his enemies to eternal destruction, and
272
his friends to eternal punishment. And the height of insanity is in believing that while in-
ternal contest occasions the injury of the members of Hyle, victory brings punishment to
the members of God. What means this folly? To use Faustus’ comparison of God and Hyle
to the antidote and poison, the antidote seems to be more mischievous than the poison.
We do not hear of Hyle shutting up God for ever in a mass of darkness, or driving its own
members into it; or, which is worst of all, slandering this unfortunate remnant, as an excuse
for not effecting its purification. For Manichæus, in his Fundamental Epistle, says that these
souls deserved to be thus punished, because they allowed themselves to be led away from
their original brightness, and became enemies of holy light; whereas it was God himself that
sent them to lose themselves in the region of darkness, that light might be opposed to light:
which was unjust, if he forced them against their will; while, if they went willingly, he is
ungrateful in punishing them. These souls can never have been happy, if they were tormented
with fear before the conflict, from knowing that they were to become enemies to their ori-
ginal principle, and then in the conflict were hopelessly contaminated, and afterwards
eternally condemned. On the other hand, they can never have been divine, if before the
conflict they were unaware of what was coming, from want of prescience, and then showed
feebleness in the conflict, and suffered misery afterwards. And what is true of them must
be true of God, since they are of the same substance. Is there any hope of your seeing the
folly of these blasphemies? You attempt, indeed, to vindicate the goodness of God, by as-
serting that Hyle when shut up is prevented from doing any more injury to itself. Hyle, it
seems, is to get some good, when it has no longer any good mixed with it. Perhaps, as God
before the conflict had the evil of necessity, when the good was unmixed with evil, so Hyle
after the conflict is to have the good of rest, when the evil is unmixed with good. Your
principles are thus either two evils, one worse than the other; or two goods, both imperfect,
but one better than the other. The better, however, is the more miserable; for if the issue of
this great conflict is that the enemy gets some good by the cessation of mutual injuries in
Hyle, while God’s own subjects suffer the serious evil of being driven into the mass of
darkness, we may ask who has got the victory. The poison, we are to understand, is Hyle,
where, nevertheless, animal life found a plentiful supply of the means of growth and pro-
ductiveness; while the antidote is God, who could condemn his own members, but could
463
Faustus denies that Manichæans believe in two gods. Hyle no god. Augustin…