last fall, two young men belonging to the church at New-Haven, who had been members
of Mr. Noyes’s church, but had left it and joined the separate church, and entered into cov-
enant with it, when that church was embodied. This was looked upon as a crime, that ought
not to be passed over, by Mr. Noyes and the rector. They declared themselves willing to return
to Mr. Noyes’s meeting; but a particular confession was required of them in the meeting-
lxxvii
house. Accordingly, each of them had offered a confession, but it was not thought sufficient;
but it was required that they should add some things, of which they thought hard; and they
consulting me about it, I acquainted Col. Stoddard with the affair, and desired his thoughts.
He said he looked upon it unreasonable to require any confession at all; and that, considering
the general state of confusion that had existed, and the instructions and examples these
young men had had, it might well be looked upon enough, that they were now willing to
change their practice, and return again to Mr. Noyes’s meeting. Not that you, Rev. Sir, are
obliged to think as Col. Stoddard does; yet I think, considering his character and relation,
his judgment may well be of so much weight, as to engage you the more to attend to and
weigh the reasons he gives.
The objections, that these persons may have had against ordinarily attending your
meeting, may be very trivial; but yet I suppose that, through infirmity, the case may be so
with truly honest Christians, that trivial things may have great weight in their consciences,
so as to have fast hold of them, until they are better enlightened: as in the former times of
the country, it was with respect to the controversy between presbyterians and congregation-
alists. It was, as I have heard, in those days real matter of question with some, whether a
presbyterian, living and dying such, could be saved. Some presbyterians, that have lived
with us, have desired baptism for their children, who yet lived in neglect of the ordinances
of the Lord Jesus Christ, because of a difference in some trivial circumstances of the admin-
istration, from the method of the church of Scotland. This matter being discoursed of, it
was thought by Col. Stoddard in particular, that their neglect ought to be borne with, and
they ought to be looked upon as Christians, and their children received to baptism; because,
however trivial the foundation of their scruples were, yet through ignorance they might be
honest and conscientious in them.
As to the church covenant, that these persons have entered into, wherein they have
obliged themselves ordinarily to join in the worship of that church; I suppose none interpret
the promises of a church covenant in such a sense, as to exclude all reserves of liberty, in
case of an alteration of the judgment, in the affairs of conscience and religion, in one respect
or another. As if a person, after incorporating with a congregational church, should become
a conscientious episcopalian, or anabaptist, or should, by any change of judgment, come to
think the means or manner of worship unlawful; and so in other respects that might be
mentioned.
152
Chapter XIII. First Interview with David Brainerd--Separations From Churches--Letter…