Chapter 18.—20. He says: "You who are a most abandoned traditor have come out in
the character of a persecutor and murderer of us who keep the law." If the followers of
Maximianus kept the law when they separated from you, then we may acknowledge you as
a keeper of the law, when you are separated from the Church spread abroad throughout the
world. But if you raise the question of persecutions, I at once reply: If you have suffered
anything unjustly, this does not concern those who, though they disapprove of men who
act in such a way,1949 yet endure them for the peace that is in unity, in a manner deserving
of all praise. Wherefore you have nothing to bring up against the Lord’s wheat, who endure
the chaff that is among them till the last winnowing, from whom you never would have
separated yourself, had you not shown yourself lighter than chaff by flying away under the
blast of temptation before the coming of the Winnower. But not to leave this one example,
which the Lord hath thrust back in their teeth, to close the mouths of these men, for their
correction if they will show themselves to be wise, but for their confusion if they remain in
their folly: if those are more just that suffer persecution than those who inflict it, then those
same followers of Maximianus are the more just, whose basilica was utterly overthrown,
and who were grievously maltreated by the military following of Optatus, when the mandates
of the proconsul, ordering that all of them should be shut out of the basilicas, were manifestly
procured by the followers of Primianus. Wherefore, if, when the emperors hated their
communion, they ventured on such violent measures for the persecution of the followers
526
of Maximianus, what would they do if they were enabled to work their will by being in
communion with kings? And if they did such things as I have mentioned for the correction
of the wicked, why are they surprised that Catholic emperors should decree with greater
power that they should be worked upon and corrected who endeavor to rebaptize the whole
Christian world, when they have no ground for differing from them? seeing that they,
themselves bear witness that it is right to bear with wicked men even where they have true
charges to bring against them in the cause of peace, since they received those whom they
had themselves condemned, acknowledging the honors conferred among themselves, and
the baptism administered in schism. Let them at length consider what treatment they deserve
at the hands of the Christian powers of the world, who are the enemies of Christian unity
throughout the world. If, therefore, correction be bitter, yet let them not fail to be ashamed;
lest when they begin to read what they themselves have written, they be overcome with
laughter, when they do not find in themselves what they wish to find in others, and fail to
recognize1950 in their own case what they find fault with in their neighbors.
1949 Qui talia facientes quamvis improbent. A comparison of the explanation of this passage in Contra
Crescon. III. 41, 45, shows the probability of Migne’s conjecture, "quamvis improbe," "who endure the men that
act in such a way, however monstrous their conduct may be."
1950 Nec in se agnoscunt. The reading of the Louvain edition gives better sense, "Et in se agnoscunt," "and
discover in themselves."
Chapter 18
999
Chapter 18