THEOLOGY
first year—he had already shown himself to be a graceful and
forcible writer on theological subjects, with a strong tendency to
broad and philosophical opinions, and his appointment was
furthered by Baron Bunsen, one of whose works he had
reviewed. His promotion aroused strong hopes in the young
men who wished for more light in theology ; Edward Caird and
Robert Herbert Story were among his first students. His power
and influence increased with years both in the University and in
the Church, and he must be judged to have done as much as
any other single man to lift theology in Scotland out of its
enthralment and to introduce reasonable ways of thinking as to
the nature and the claims of religious truth. Many are living
who attended his class and can speak of the spirit and methods
of his teaching.
Tulloch's influence was felt by his class far more in what
may be called his casual and side remarks than in his formal
lectures. The former sprang like sparks from an anvil, with
all the effect of surprise, and often charged with the feeling
of the moment. The lectures may be judged of partly by
the Burnet Prize Essay on Theism, which a portion of them
reproduced in a slightly modified form, while the Croall Lecture*
on the Doctrine of Sin were the class lectures on that subject
carefully worked over. But when he threw himself back in his
chair and talked, he held the attention riveted. He frequently
devoted one day a week to giving an account and abstract of
some book he was reading at the time: these discussions
were very interesting. He had great power in sketching the
spirit and tendency of an age or an individual. He had a real
insight into history without being strong in details. Examples
of his work in this direction are his Leaders of the Refor-
mation and his English Puritanism and its Leaders. The same
power is discernible in his chief book, Rational Theology
and Christian Philosophy in England in the Seventeenth Century,
121