1868-71] "FREE CHRISTIAN UNION" 259
inhaled a sniff of the " fresh woods and pastures new " of
heresy, you should have got again entangled amid the
"
beggarly elements
"
; but it must ever be a great difficulty
to find a common platform for the respective votaries of
Natural and Unnatural Religion. Don't think that is a
mere verbal taunt; it is a sad and serious thought, and
indicates, I believe, the rapidly approaching line of religious
controversy that is gradually to divide our Protestant
world
; what I dread is its also dividing the religion of our
men from that of our priests and women.
The same to the same
THE RED HOUSE, 21 st June, 1868.
As to the Free Christian Union : of course no one can
feel that their belief is retrograding, and no one can con-
sciously believe in beggarly elements ; what we believe in,
of course, seems to us precious wealth, and I might as well,
perhaps better, have refrained from the expression of my
protest. I fancy the fact is that I differ from you and
Katy as to the meaning of the word Church, and as to the
proper basis of union for a worshipping Society. Those
who believe in exclusive salvation must fence their union
round with those dogmas " which except a man believe
he cannot be saved
"
; but those who believe that to say
so is blasphemy seem to me only consistent when they
declare that the sole basis needed for a worshipping Society
(that is, in my view, for a Church) is " filial piety and
brotherly love." And it is only as a required bond of a
worshipping Society that the Free Christian Union dis-
approves of more detailed dogmas, not in the least denying
their value, and even necessity, as an extension of indi-
vidual conviction, and of course also a special bond of
spiritual sympathy between individuals sharing their belief.
In religious sympathy, as in every human bond, we are
each the centre of a number of concentric circles, and
though I admit that the Free Christian Union is a wide
one, yet undoubtedly the real Church, in which the human