of God, and according to the flesh was made unto Him of the seed of David. Since you have
always denied and always will deny this, how do you so earnestly demand the Scriptures
that we should discuss rather according to them.
Fortunatussaid: You assert that according to the flesh Christ was of the seed of David,
when it should be asserted that he was born of a virgin,238 and should be magnified as Son
of God. For this cannot be, unless as what is from spirit may be held to be spirit, so also
what is from flesh may be known to be flesh.239 Against which is the authority of the Gospel
in which it is said, that "flesh and blood shall not inherit the kingdom of God, neither shall
corruption inherit incorruption."240
Here a clamor was made by the audience who wished the argument to be conducted
on rational grounds, because they saw that Fortunatus was not willing to receive all things
that are written in the Codex of the apostle. Then little discussions began to be held here
and there by all, until Fortunatus said that the Word of God has been fettered in the race of
darkness. At which, when those present had expressed their horror, the meeting was closed.
241
238 Isa. vii. 14.
239 John iii. 6.
240 1 Cor. xv. 50.
241 This little side remark lends reality to the discussion, and enables us to form a vivid conception of what
doctrinal debates were in the age of Augustin.—A.H.N.
197
Disputation of the First Day.