517
The Synod held at Carthage over which presided the Great and Holy Martyr Cyprian,
Bishop of Carthage.
a.d. 257.
(Found in Beveridge, Synodicon, Tom. I., p. 365, and in Labbe and Cossart, Concilia,
Tom. I., col. 786.)
When very many bishops were met together at Carthage on the Calends of September
from the province of Africa, Numidia and Mauritania, with the presbyters and deacons (the
greater part of the people being likewise present) and when the holy letters of Jubaianus to
Cyprian had been read, and Cyprian’s answers to Jubaianus, concerning heretical baptisms,
as well as what the same Jubaianus afterwards wrote to Cyprian,
Cyprian said: Ye have heard, my dearly beloved colleagues, what our fellow bishop
Jubaianus has written to me, taking counsel of my littleness concerning the illicit and profane
baptisms of heretics, and the answer which I made him; being of the same opinion as we
have been on former occasions, that heretics coming to the Church should be baptized and
sanctified with the Church’s baptism. Moreover there has been read to you also the other
letter of Jubaianus, in which answering for his sincere and pious devotion to our letter, not
only he agrees therewith but offered thanks that he has been so instructed by it. It only re-
mains therefore that we, each one of us, one by one, say what our mind is in this matter,
without condemning any one or removing any one from the right of communion who does
not agree with us.
For no one [of us504] has set himself up [to be] bishop [of bishops],505 or attempted
with tyrannical dread to force his colleagues to obedience to him, since every bishop has,
for the license of liberty and power, his own will, and as he cannot be judged by another, so
neither can he judge another. But we await the judgment of our universal Lord, our Lord
Jesus Christ, who one and alone hath the power, both of advancing us in the governance of
his Church, and of judging of our actions [in that position].
[The bishops then one by one declared against heretical baptism.506 Last of all (col. 796)]:
Cyprian, the Confessor and Martyr of Carthage, said: The letter which was written to
Jubaianus, my colleague, most fully set forth my opinion, that heretics who, according to
the evangelical and apostolic witness, are called adversaries of Christ’s and anti-Christs,
when they come to the Church, should be baptized with the one (unico) baptism of the
504 These words are omitted in Zonaras’s Greek! The very gist of the matter for the Easterns.
505 These words are omitted in Zonaras’s Greek! The very gist of the matter for the Easterns.
506 These will be found translated in full in the Oxford “Library of the Fathers,” Vol. 17. “St. Cyprian’s
Epistles,” p. 286; also in the American reprint of the “Ante-Nicene Fathers,” Vol. V. “Hippolitus, Cyprian, etc.,”
p. 565.
The Synod held at Carthage over which presided the Great and Holy Martyr Cyprian, Bishop of Carthage.
979
The Synod held at Carthage over which presided the Great and Holy Martyr…