33. But the games which you
celebrate, called
Floralia
and
Megalensia
,
4926
and all the
rest which you wish to be sacred, and to be considered religious
duties, what reason have they, what cause, that it was necessary that
they should be instituted and founded and designated by the
names
4927
of
deities? The gods are honoured by these, says
my opponent
;
and if they have any recollection of offences committed
4928
by men,
they lay it aside, get rid of it, and show themselves gracious to us
again, their friendship being renewed. And what is the cause,
again, that they are made quite calm and gentle, if absurd things are
done, and idle fellows sport before the eyes of the multitude?
Does Jupiter lay aside his resentment if the
Amphitryon
of
Plautus is acted and declaimed? or if Europa, Leda, Ganymede, or
Danæ is represented by dancing does he restrain his passionate
impulses? Is the Great Mother rendered more calm, more gentle, if
she beholds the old story of Attis furbished up by the players?
Will Venus forget her displeasure if she sees mimics act the part of
Adonis also in a ballet?
4929
Does the anger of Alcides die
away if the tragedy of Sophocles named
Trachiniæ
, or the
Hercules
of Euripides, is acted? or does Flora think
4930
that honour is
shown to her if at her games she sees that shameful actions are done,
and the stews abandoned for the theatres? Is not this, then, to
lessen the dignity of the gods, to dedicate and consecrate to them the
basest things which a rigidly virtuous mind will turn from with
disgust, the performers of which your law has decided to be dishonoured
and to be considered infamous? The gods, forsooth, delight in
mimics; and that surpassing excellence which has not been comprehended
by any human faculty, opens
4931
its ears most willingly to hear these
plays
, with most of which they know they are mixed up to be
turned to derision; they are delighted, as it is, with the shaved heads
of the fools, by the sound of flaps, and by the
noise of
applause, by shameful actions and words, by huge red
fascina
. But further, if they see men weakening themselves
to the effeminacy of women, some vociferating uselessly, others running
about without cause,
4932
others, while their friendship is
unbroken, bruising and maiming each with the bloody
cestus
,
these contending in
speaking without drawing
breath,
4933
swelling
out their cheeks with wind, and shouting out noisily empty vows, do
they lift up their hands to heaven
in their admiration
, start up
moved by
such
wonders, burst into exclamations, again become
gracious to men? If these things cause the gods to forget their
resentment, if they derive the highest pleasure from comedies, Atellane
farces,
and
pantomimes, why do you delay, why do you hesitate,
to say that the gods themselves also play, act lasciviously, dance,
compose obscene songs, and undulate with trembling
haunches?
For what
difference is there, or what does it matter, whether they do these
things themselves, or are pleased and delighted to see them done by
others?
4926
The former dedicated to Flora (cf. iii. 25), the latter to Cybele.
4927
Singular.
4928
So the margin of Ursinus, Elm., LB., Orelli, Hild., and Oehler;
the
ms.
reading not being known.
4929
Lit., “in dancing motions.”
4930
So
Meursius, Orelli, and Oehler, reading
existimat-ve
, all
the others retaining the
ms.
-ur-
—“Is Flora thought to be treated,”
etc.
4931
Lit., “adapts.”
4932
Here also there is doubt as to what the reading of the
ms.
is. The 1st ed. reads
sine
culpa
—“without blame,” which is hardly in keeping
with the context, emended
causa
, as above, by Gelenius.
4933
So Orelli explains
certare hos spiritu
as referring to a contest
in which each strove to speak or sing with one breath longer than the
rest.