that his own position was impregnable, that he seems to have thought that if he could only
secure a thorough and dispassionate discussion of the matter, the Donatists must necessarily
be brought to acknowledge not only their theoretical errors, but also the practical sinfulness
of their separation from the Church. Throughout the controversy, however, he appears to
have put out of sight two considerations: first, the influence of party spirit and prejudice
in blinding men to argument; and, secondly, the necessity of treating his opponents in a
logical discussion as on an equal footing with himself. The first was in some degree an un-
avoidable element of disappointment; but Augustin made concession yet more difficult on
the part of his opponents, by expecting them to acknowledge his superior position as a
member of the Catholic Church, whose duty it was to expose the error of their views. He
practically begs the very point at issue, by assuming that he, and not the Donatists, was in
the Catholic communion; and though his argument is conducted independently of this
premise, yet it naturally rendered them more unwilling to admit its force.
This dogmatism was of less consequence in the first pamphlet which Augustin published
on the subject,—his Alphabetical Psalm, in which he set forth the history and errors of the
Donatists in a popular form,—since it was not intended as a controversial treatise, but only
as a means of enlightening the less educated as to the Catholic tenets on the question in
dispute. His next work, written in answer to a letter of Donatus of Carthage, in which the
latter tried to prove that the baptism of Christ existed only in his communion, is unfortu-
406
nately lost; and we can only gather hints as to the further part which he took in the contro-
versy during the next few years from certain of his letters, especially those to the Donatist
Bishops Honoratus and Crispinus.1142 From the former he claims the admission that the
exclusiveness of the Donatists proves that they are not the Church of Christ; and his letter
to the latter contains an invitation to discuss the leading points at issue, which Crispinus
seems to have declined.
In the year 400 he wrote two books Against the Party of Donatus, which are also lost;
and about the same time he published his refutation of the letter of Parmenianus in answer
to Tichonius, in which he handles and solves the famous question, whether, while abiding
in unity in the communion of the same sacraments, the wicked pollute the good by their
society.1143
Then followed his seven books On Baptism, included in this volume, in which he shows
the emptiness of the arguments of the Donatists for the repetition of baptism; and proves
that so far was Cyprian from being on their side, that his letters and conduct are of the
highest value as overthrowing their position, and utterly condemning their separation from
the Church.
1142 Epist. xlix. li.
1143 Bened. Ed. Vol. ix. pp. 7-52. Migne, Vol. ix. pp. 33-108.
691
Preface.