the grasp of your own syllogism? Who is the father of the Ungenerate? Can you say? If you
can, then He is not ungenerate. Pressed thus, you will say, what indeed necessity compels
you to say,—No one is. Well, my dear sir, do you not yet find the weak seams of your
sophism giving way? Do you not perceive that you have slavered upon your own lap? What
says our great Basil? That the Ungenerate One is from no father. For the conclusion to be
drawn from the mention of fathers in the preceding genealogy permits the word father, even
in the silence of the evangelist, to be added to this confession of faith. Whereas, you have
transformed “no one” into “nothing at all,” and again “nothing at all” into “absolute non-
entity,” thereby concocting that fallacious syllogism of yours. Accordingly this clever result
314
of professional shrewdness shall be turned against yourself. I ask, Who is the father of the
Ungenerate One? “No one,” you will be obliged to answer; for the Ungenerate One cannot
have a father. Then, if no one is the father of the Ungenerate, and you have changed “no
one” into “nothing at all,” and “nothing at all” is, according to your argument, the same as
“absolute nonentity,” and the transposition of equivalents is, as you say, perfectly legitimate,
then the man (i.e. you) who says that no one is the father of the Ungenerate One, says that
the Deity Who is over all comes from absolute nonentity!
Such, to use your own words, is the “evil,” as one might expect, not indeed “of valuing
the character for being clever before one is really such” (for perhaps this does not amount
to a very great misfortune), but of not knowing oneself, and how great the distance is between
the soaring Basil and a grovelling reptile. For if those eyes of his, with their divine penetration,
still looked on this world, if he still swept over mankind now living on the pinions of his
wisdom, he would have shown you with the swooping rush of his words, how frail is that
native shell of folly in which you are encased, how great is he whom you oppose with your
errors, while, with insults and invectives hurled at him, you are hunting for a reputation
amongst decrepit and despicable creatures. Still you need not give up all hope of feeling that
great man’s talons1219. For this work of ours, while, as compared with his, it will be a great
thing for it to be judged the fraction of one such talon, has, as regards yours, ability enough
to have broken asunder the outside crust of your heresy, and to have detected the deformity
that hides within.
1219 Πλὴν ἀλλ᾽ οὐκ ἀνελπιστέον σοι καὶ τῶν ὀνύχων ἐκείνου. Viger (De Idiotismis, p. 474), “Πλὴν ἀλλὰ
interdum repellentis est, interdum concedentis,” as here ironically and in Book I. p. 83, πλὴν ἀλλὰ καὶ ἐστὶν ἐν
θηρίοις κρίσις, “still there is some distinction between animals.”
586
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.