accuse of “pious fraud” or the next thing to it (Kestner, 1816, p. 67). For farther criticisms
consult the works cited by Dr. McGiffert under Literature, and the special works on Eusebius
cited in the Literature to Constantine above, passim. The criticisms group generally around
1. The suppression of the facts respecting the deaths of Crispus, &c., and various others
derogatory to Constantine. 2. The eulogistic tone and coloring of the work, especially the
very pietistic saintly sort of flavor given to Constantine.
As to the suppression of facts, note (1) That he gives entire warning of his plan. It would
have been artistically and ethically improper, in a work which distinctly sets out with such
purpose, to admit that class of facts. It takes more or less from the value of the work, but it
does not reflect on the general trustworthiness of what is said. (2) No similar judgment is
passed on Eutropius, the Victors, Anonymous Valesianus or Zosimus, for not mentioning
his pious acts. (3) A comparison of most biographies of living and dead presidents, kings,
and emperors will be greatly to the advantage, even, of this fourth century eulogist over
those of our boasted critical age.
As to the eulogistic and exaggerated tone, observe (1) That it was more or less justified.
That is, the premises of the criticism which are substantially that Constantine was not saintly
or pietistic and was non-committal toward Christianity, are false. His extreme testimony is
backed by very general testimony in the election of Constantine to technical saintship. (2)
That is compares well with modern eulogists and extremely well with the contemporary
Panegyrists of Constantine. (3) That Eusebius takes care frequently to guard his statements
by quoting his source, as in the matter of the vision of the cross, or by ascribing to hearsay.
In general, the work stands much on the same level as the biographies of generals in the
late civil war, or of presidents, written by admiring members of their staffs or cabinets, in-
469
corporating authentic documents, intending to be truthful, and generally succeeding, but
yet full of the enthusiasm of admiring friendship and inclined not to see, or to extenuate or
even suppress, faults and mistakes. Nevertheless, they are valuable on the positive side as
the real testimony to genuinely believed excellency by those in the position to know intim-
ately. Eusebius is, substantially, genuine. Such supreme hypocrisy as would produce this
work, without admiring respect and after its subject was dead, is inconceivable in him. All
the unconscious turns of phrase show at least a consistent attitude of mind. The work is, in
brief, by a competent author, from ample sources and without intentional falsification or
misrepresentation. It probably represents the current Christian view of the man as accurately
and honestly as any biography of Lincoln or the Emperor William written within a year or
two of their deaths has done. As we now think of these two men whom doubtless inquisitive
criticism might find to have faults, so the Christians in general and his friend Eusebius in
particular thought of the Great Emperor. Compare discussion and literature of the trustwor-
thiness of Eusebius as a historical writer in the Prolegomena of Dr. McGiffert in this volume.
6. Value of the Work
1143
The Life of Constantine.