24
engage in any such doctrinal strife; but he was compelled to defend himself, and in doing
so he could not do otherwise than accuse Eustathius of Sabellianism; for if the latter was
not satisfied with Eusebius’ orthodoxy, which Eusebius himself believed to be truly Nicene,
then he must be leaning too far toward the other extreme; that is, toward Sabellianism. There
is no reason to doubt that Eusebius was perfectly straightforward and honorable throughout
the whole controversy, and at the Council of Antioch itself. That he was not actuated by
unworthy motives, or by a desire for revenge, is evinced by his rejection of the proffered
call to Antioch, the acceptance of which would have given him so good an opportunity to
triumph over his fallen enemy. It must be admitted, in fact, that Eusebius comes out of this
controversy without a stain of any kind upon his character. He honestly believed Eustathius
to be a Sabellian, and he acted accordingly.
Eusebius has been blamed still more severely for his treatment of Athanasius. But again
the facts must be looked at impartially. It is necessary always to remember that Sabellianism
was in the beginning and remained throughout his life the heresy which he most dreaded,
and which he had perhaps most reason to dread. He must, even at the Council of Nicæa,
have suspected Athanasius, who laid so much stress upon the unity of essence on the part
of Father and Son, of a leaning toward Sabellianistic principles; and this suspicion must
have been increased when he discovered, as he believed, that Athanasius’ most staunch
supporter, Eustathius, was a genuine Sabellian. Moreover, on the other side, it is to be re-
membered that Eusebius of Nicomedia, and all the other leading Arians, had signed the
Nicene creed and had proclaimed themselves thoroughly in sympathy with its teaching.
Our Eusebius, knowing the change that had taken place in his own mind upon the contro-
verted points, may well have believed that their views had undergone even a greater change,
and that they were perfectly honest in their protestations of orthodoxy. And finally, when
Arius himself presented a confession of faith which led the Emperor, who had had a personal
interview with him, to believe that he had altered his views and was in complete harmony
with the Nicene faith, it is not surprising that our Eusebius, who was naturally unsuspicious,
conciliatory and peace-loving, should think the same thing, and be glad to receive Arius
back into communion, while at the same time remaining perfectly loyal to the orthodoxy
of the Nicene creed which he had subscribed. Meanwhile his suspicions of the Arian party
being in large measure allayed, and his distrust of the orthodoxy of Athanasius and of his
adherents being increased by the course of events, it was only natural that he should lend
more or less credence to the calumnies which were so industriously circulated against Ath-
anasius. To charge him with dishonesty for being influenced by these reports, which seem
to us so absurd and palpably calumnious, is quite unwarranted. Constantine, who was, if
not a theologian, at least a clear-headed and sharp-sighted man, believed them, and why
should Eusebius not have done the same? The incident which took place at the Council of
Tyre in connection with Potamo and himself was important; for whatever doubts he may
38
Continuance of the Arian Controversy. Eusebius' Relations to the Two Pa…