Chapter XI.—Symeon rules the Church of Jerusalem after James.
1. After the martyrdom of James691 and the conquest of Jerusalem which immediately
followed,692 it is said that those of the apostles and disciples of the Lord that were still living
came together from all directions with those that were related to the Lord according to the
flesh693 (for the majority of them also were still alive) to take counsel as to who was worthy
to succeed James.
2. They all with one consent pronounced Symeon,694 the son of Clopas, of whom the
Gospel also makes mention;695 to be worthy of the episcopal throne of that parish. He was
691 61 or 62 a.d. See above, Bk. II. chap. 23.
692 See ibid. note 40. The date of Symeon’s accession (assuming that he did take charge of the Jerusalem
church as James had done) cannot be fixed. Eusebius himself, as he informs us in Bk. IV. chap. 5, although he
had a list of the Jerusalem bishops, had no information as to the dates of their accession, or the length of their
incumbency. He puts Symeon’s accession after the destruction of Jerusalem, but he evidently does that only
because he supposed that it followed immediately upon the death of James. Some (e.g. Lightfoot) think it probable
that Symeon was appointed immediately after James’ death, therefore before the destruction of Jerusalem; others
(e.g. Renan) suppose that in Pella they had no bishop and appointed Symeon only after the return of the church
to Jerusalem.
693 λόγος κατέχει. Hegesippus (quoted in Bk. IV. chap. 22, below) says that “Symeon was appointed the
second bishop, whom all proposed as the cousin of our Lord.” Upon what authority Eusebius’ more definite
account rests we do not know. He introduces it with the formula λόγος κατέχει, and we know of no other author
who has put it as he does. It may be that the simple statement of Hegesippus was the sole ground of the more
detailed tradition which Eusebius repeats in this chapter. The reason of Symeon’s appointment as given by
Hegesippus is quite significant. It was the common Oriental custom to accord the highest honors to all the
members of a prophet’s or religious leader’s family, and it was undoubtedly owing chiefly to his close physical
relationship to Christ that James enjoyed such prominence and influence in the Jerusalem church, apparently
exceeding even that of the apostles themselves.
694 This Symeon is to be distinguished from the apostle Simon, the Canaanite, and also from Simon, the
brother of our Lord (mentioned in Matt. xiii. 55 and Mark vi. 3). It is noticeable that Hegesippus nowhere calls
him the “brother of the Lord,” though he does give James that title in Bk. II. chap. 23. Clopas is mentioned in
John xix. 25, as the husband of Mary, who is without doubt identical with Mary the mother of James (the little)
and of Joses; mentioned in Matt. xxvii. 56, Mark xv. 40, &c. If Hegesippus’ account be accepted as trustworthy
(and there is no reason for doubting it), Symeon was the son of Clopas and Mary, and therefore brother of James
the Little and Joses. If, then, Alphæus and Clopas be the same, as many claim, James the Little is to be identified
with James the son of Alphæus, the apostle, and hence the latter was the brother of Symeon. This identification,
however, is entirely arbitrary, and linguistically difficult, and we shall do better therefore to keep the men separate,
as Renan does (see above, Bk. I. chap. 12, note 14). Upon the martyrdom of Symeon, see below, chap. 32.
695 In John xix. 25
Symeon rules the Church of Jerusalem after James.
289
Symeon rules the Church of Jerusalem after James.