OBJECT. XI.
You may as well say, that unsanctified persons may not attend any duty of divine worship
whatsoever, as that they may not attend the Lord’s supper; for all duties of worship are holy
and require holiness, in order to an acceptable performance of them, as well as that.
Answ. If this argument has any foundation at all, it has its foundation in the supposed
truth of the following propositions, viz. Whosoever is qualified for admission to one duty of
divine worship, is qualified for admission to all; and he that is unqualified for one, and may
be forbidden one, is unqualified for all, and ought to be allowed to attend none. But certainly
these propositions are not true. There are many qualified for some duties of worship, and
may be allowed to attend them, who yet are not qualified for some others, nor by any means
to be admitted to them. As every body grants, the unbaptized, the excommunicated, heretics,
scandalous livers, &c. may be admitted to hear the word preached; nevertheless they are not
to be allowed to come to the Lord’s supper. Even excommunicated persons remain still
under the law of the Sabbath, and are not to be forbidden to observe the Lord’s day. Ignorant
persons, such as have not knowledge sufficient for an approach to the Lord’s table, yet are
not excused from the duty of prayer: they may pray to God to instruct them, and assist them
in obtaining knowledge. They who have been educated in Arianism and Socinianism, and
are not yet brought off from these fundamental errors, and so are by no means to be admitted
to the Lord’s supper, yet may pray to God to assist them in their studies, and guide them
into the truth, and for all other mercies which they need. Socrates, that great Gentile philo-
sopher, who worshipped the true God, as he was led by the light of nature, might pray to
God, and he attended his duty when he did so; although he knew not the revelation which
God had made of himself in his word. That great philosopher, Seneca, who was contemporary
with the apostle Paul, held one Supreme Being, and had in many respects right notions of
the divine perfections and providence, though he did not embrace the gospel, which at that
day was preached in the world: yet might pray to that Supreme Being whom he acknowledged.
And if his brother Gallio at Corinth, when Paul preached there, had prayed to this Supreme
Being to guide him into the truth, that he might know whether the doctrine Paul preached
was true, he therein would have acted very becoming a reasonable creature, and any one
472
would have acted unreasonably in forbidding him; but yet surely neither of these men was
qualified for the christian sacrament. So that it is apparent there is and ought to be a distinc-
tion made between duties of worship, with respect to qualifications for them; and that which
is a sufficient qualification for admission to one duty, is not so for all. And therefore the
position is not true, which is the foundation whereon the whole weight of this argument
rests. To say, that although it be true there ought to be a distinction made, in admission to
duties of worship, with regard to some qualifications, yet sanctifying grace is not one of
those qualifications that make the difference; would be but giving up the argument, and a
perfect begging the question.
OBJ. XI. All duties of worship holy.
1856
OBJ. XI. All duties of worship holy.