“If the Son is subjected to the Father in the Godhead, then He must have been subjected
from the beginning, from whence He was God. But if He was not subjected, but shall be
subjected, it is in the manhood, as for us, not in the Godhead, as for Himself.”
Philipp. ii. 9. On the Name above every Name.
“If the name above every name was given by the Father to the Son, Who was God, and
every tongue owned Him Lord, after the incarnation, because of His obedience, then before
the incarnation He neither had the name above every name nor was owned by all to be
Lord. It follows then that after the incarnation He was greater than before the incarnation,
which is absurd.” So of Matt. xxviii. 18. “We must understand this of the incarnation, and
not of the Godhead.”
John xiv. 28. “My Father is Greater than I.”
“‘Greater’ is predicated in bulk, in time, in dignity, in power, or as cause. The Father
cannot be called greater than the Son in bulk, for He is incorporeal: nor yet in time, for the
Son is Creator of times: nor yet in dignity, for He was not made what He had once not
been: nor yet in power, for ‘what things the Father doeth, these also doeth the son like-
wise’:374 nor as cause, since (the Father) would be similarly greater than He and than we,
if He is cause of Him and of us. The words express rather the honour given by the Son to
the Father than any depreciation by the speaker; moreover what is greater is not necessarily
of a different essence. Man is called greater than man, and horse than horse. If the Father
is called greater, it does not immediately follow that He is of another substance. In a word,
the comparison lies between beings of one substance, not between those of different sub-
stances.375
“A man is not properly said to be greater than a brute, than an inanimate thing, but
man than man and brute than brute. The Father is therefore of one substance with the Son,
even though He be called greater.”376
374 John v. 19.
375 ἐπὶ τῶν ὁμοουσίων οὐκ ἐπὶ τῶν ἑτεροουσίων.
376 It will be noted that Basil explains this passage on different grounds from those suggested by the Clause
in the Athanasian Creed, on which Waterland’s remark is that it “needs no comment.” St. Athanasius himself
interpreted the “minority” not of the humanity, or of the special subordination of the time when the words were
uttered. cf. Ath., Orat. c. Ar. i. § 58: “The Son says not ‘my Father is better than I,’ lest we should conceive Him
to be foreign to His nature, but ‘greater,’ not indeed in size, nor in time, but because of His generation from the
Father Himself; nay, in saying ‘greater,’ He again shews that He is proper to His essence” (Newman’s transl.).
The explanation given in Letter viii., p. 118, does include the inferiority as touching His manhood.
63
Dogmatic.