week it should happen to be. But it was not the custom of the churches in the rest of the
world to end it at this time, as they observed the practice which, from apostolic tradition,
has prevailed to the present time, of terminating the fast on no other day than on that of
the resurrection of our Saviour.
2. Synods and assemblies of bishops were held on this account,1688 and all, with one
consent, through mutual correspondence drew up an ecclesiastical decree, that the mystery
to all who observed the fourteenth day, even those of the second and third centuries. This brief summary will
enable us better to understand the accounts of Eusebius, who is our chief authority on the subject. The paschal
controversy has had an important bearing upon the question of the authenticity of the fourth Gospel, the
Tübingen critics having drawn from this controversy one of their strongest arguments against its genuineness.
This subject cannot be discussed here, but the reader is referred, for a brief statement of the case, to Schaff’s Ch.
Hist. II. 219. The Johannine controversy has given rise to an extensive literature on these paschal disputes.
Among the most important’ works are Hilgenfeld’s Der Paschastreit der alten Kirche nach seiner Bedeutung fur
die Kirchengesch. u. s. w.; and Schürer’s Die Paschastreitigkeiten des zweiten Jahrhunderts, in the Zeitschrift für
hist. Theologie, 1870, p. 182–284,—the latter perhaps the ablest extended discussion of the subject extant. The
reader is also referred to the article Easter, in Smith’s Dict. of Christ. Ant.; to Hefele’s Conciliengesch. I. p. 86–101;
and especially to the chapter on the paschal controversies in Schaff’s Ch. Hist. Vol. II. p. 209–220. This chapter
of Schaff’s is the clearest, and, in the opinion of the writer, by far the most satisfactory, brief statement of the
whole subject which we have.
1688 Although other synods are mentioned by the Libellus synodicus (of the ninth century), the only ones
which we have good reason for accepting are those mentioned by Eusebius in this chapter and the next; viz. one
in Palestine (the Libellus synodicus gives two: one at Jerusalem, presided over by Narcissus, and another at
Cæsarea, presided over by Theophilus, but the report is too late to be of authority); one in Pontus, under the
presidency of Palmas; one in Gaul, under Irenæus; one in Osrhoëne in Mesopotamia; and one in Asia Minor,
under Polycrates. Hefele (Conciliengesch. I. p. 101) adds one in Rome under Victor; and although Eusebius does
not distinctly mention such a synod, we are undoubtedly to conclude that the epistle written by Victor was a
synodical epistle and hence Hefele is, in all probability, correct in assuming that some kind of a synod, whether
municipal or provincial, took place there at this time (see note 4). From the words of Eusebius at the close of
the chapter, we may gather that still other synods than those mentioned by him were held on this subject. The
date of all of these councils is commonly given as 198 a.d., but there is no particular authority for that year.
Jerome’s version of the Chron. assigns the composition of the various epistles to the fourth year of Septimius
Severus (196–197); but it is clear that he is giving only an approximate date. We can say only that the synods
took place sometime during Victor’s episcopate. All the councils, as we learn from this chapter, except the one
under Polycrates in Asia Minor, decided against the Quartodeciman practice. Athanasius, however (de Syn. c.
5), speaks of Christians of Syria, Cilicia, and Mesopotamia as celebrating the paschal feast on the fourteenth
day; and Jerome (de vir. ill. c. 35) says that many bishops of Asia and of the Orient kept up this observance. It is
possible that the practice was from the beginning more widely spread than Eusebius supposed, or, what is more
probable, that the words of Athanasius and Jerome refer to individual churches and bishops, whose observance
577
The Question then agitated concerning the Passover.