Chapter XVIII
.—
The Letter of Athanasius, Bishop of Alexandria,
concerning the same Council.
The
great Athanasius also, in his letter to the Africans, writes thus
about the council at Ariminum. “Under these circumstances who
will tolerate any mention of the council of Ariminum or any other
beside the Nicene? Who would not express detestation of the setting
aside of the words of the Fathers, and the preference for those
introduced at Ari
minum by violence and party strife? Who would wish to be
associated with these men—fellows who do not, forsooth, accept
their own words? In their own ten or a dozen synods they have laid
down, as has been narrated already, now one thing now another; and at
the present time these synods, one after another, they are themselves
openly denouncing. They are now suffering the fate undergone of old by
the traitors of the Jews. For as is written in the Book of the Prophet
Jeremiah “
they have forsaken me the fountain of living waters
and hewed them out cisterns, broken cisterns that can hold no
water,
”
565
so these men, in
their opposition to the Œcumenical synod, have hewed for
themselves many synods which have all proved vain and like
“
buds that yield no meal,
”
566
let
us not therefore admit those who cite the council of Ariminum or any
other but that of Nicæa, for indeed the very citers of Ariminum do
not seem to know what was done there; if they had they would have held
their tongues. For you, beloved, have learnt from your own
representatives at that Council, and are consequently very well aware,
that Ursacius, Valens, Eudoxius, and Auxentius, and with them
Demophilus were asked to anathematize the Arian heresy, and made
excuse, choosing rather to be its champions, and so were all deposed
for making propositions contrary to the Nicene decrees. The bishops, on
the contrary, who were the true servants of the Lord, and of the right
faith,—about two hundred in number,—declared their
adherence to the Nicene Council alone, and their refusal to entertain
the thought of either subtraction from, or addition to, its decrees.
This conclusion they have communicated to Constantius, by whose order
the council assembled.
On the other hand the bishops
who were deposed at Ariminum have been received by Constantius, and
have succeeded in getting the two hundred who sentenced them grossly
insulted, and threatened with not being allowed to return to their
dioceses, and with having to undergo rigorous treatment in Thrace, and
that in the winter, in order to force them to accept the
innovators’ measures.
If, then, we hear any one
appealing to Ariminum, show us, let us rejoin, first the sentence of
deposition, and then the document drawn up by the bishops, in which
they declare that they do not seek to go beyond the terms drawn up by
the Nicene Fathers, nor appeal to any other council than that of
Nicæa. In reality, these are just the facts they conceal, while
they put prominently forward the forced confession of Thrace. They do
but shew themselves friends of the Arian heresy, and strangers to the
sound faith. Only let any one be willing to put side by side that great
synod, and those others to which these men appeal, and he will
perceive, on the one side, true religion, on the other, folly and
disorder. The fathers of Nicæa met together not after being
deposed, but after confessing that the Son was of the Substance of the
Father. These men were deposed once, a second time, and again a third
time at Ariminum, and then dared to lay down that it is wrong to
attribute Substance or Essence to God. So strange and so many were the
tricks and machinations concocted by the mad gang of Arius in the West
against the dogmas of the Truth.
565
Jer. ii. 13
566
Hosea
viii. 7
. The text “
δράγματα μὴ
ἔχοντα
ἵσχύν
” recalls
the septuagint
δράγμα οὐκ
ἔχον ἴσχύν