11. After the exposition of his faith, or rather his lack of
knowledge, he passes on to another matter; and tries to make excuses
for having turned the books
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
into
Latin. I will put down his words literally:
“I am told that objections
have been raised against me because, forsooth, at the request of some
of my brethren, I translated certain works of Origen from Greek into
Latin. I suppose that every one sees that it is only through ill-will
that this is made a matter of blame. For, if there is any offensive
statement in the author, why is this to be twisted into a fault
of
the
translator? I was asked to exhibit in Latin what stands written in the
Greek text; and I did nothing more than fit Latin words to Greek ideas.
If, therefore, there is anything to praise in these ideas, the praise
does not belong to me: and similarly as to anything to which blame may
attach.”
“I hear,” he says,
“that thence
dispute
has arisen.”
3111
How clever this is, to speak of it as a
dispute, when it is really an accusation against him. “That I
have, at the request of my brethren, translated certain things of
Origen’s into Latin.” Yes, but what are these
“
certain things
”? Have they no name? Are you silent?
Then the bills of charge brought by the accusers will speak for you.
“I suppose,” he says, “that every one understands
that it is only through envy that these things are made matters of
blame.” What envy? Are people envious of your eloquence? Or have
you done what no other man has ever been able to do? Here am I, who
have translated many works of Origen’s; yet, except you, no one
shews envy towards me or calumniates me for it. “If there is any
offensive statement in the author, why is it to be twisted into a fault
of the translator? I was asked to exhibit in Latin what stands written
in the Greek text; and I did nothing more than fit Latin words to Greek
ideas. If, therefore, there is anything to praise in these ideas, the
praise does not belong to me, and similarly as to anything to which
blame may attach.” Can you be astonished that men think ill of
you when you say of open blasphemies nothing more than, “If there
are any offensive statements in the author”? What is said in
those books is offensive to all men; and you stand alone in your doubt
and in your complaint that this is “twisted into a fault of the
translator,” when you have praised it in your Preface. ‘You
were asked to turn it into Latin as it stood in the Greek text.’
I wish you had done what you pretend you were asked. You would not then
be the object of any ill will. If you had kept faith as a translator,
it would not have been necessary for me to counteract your false
translation by my true one. You know in your own conscience what you
added, what you subtracted, and what you altered on one side or the
other at your discretion; and after this you have the audacity to tell
us that what is good or evil is not to be attributed to you but to the
author. You shew your sense of the ill will aroused against you by
again toning down your words: and as if you were walking with your
steps in the air or on the tops of the ears of corn, you say,
“
Whether
there is praise or blame in these
opinions.” You dare not defend him, but you do not choose to
condemn him. Choose which of the two you please; the option is yours;
if this which you have translated is good, praise it, if bad, condemn
it. But he makes excuses, and weaves another artifice, He
says:
“I admit that I put
something of my own into the work: as I stated in my Preface, I used my
own discretion in cutting out not a few passages; but only those as to
which I had come to suspect that the thing had not been so stated by
Origen himself, and the statement appeared to me in these cases to have
been inserted by others, because in other places I had found the author
state the same matter in a catholic sense.”
3112
What wonderful eloquence!
Varied, too, with flowers of the Attic style. “Moreover
also!”
3113
and “Things which came to me
into suspicion!” I marvel that he should have dared to send such
literary portents to Rome. One would think that the man’s tongue
was in fetters, and bound with cords that cannot be disentangled, so
that it could hardly break forth into human speech. However, I will
return to the matter in hand.
11 (
a
). I wish to know
who gave you permission to cut out a number of passages from the work
you were translating? You were asked to turn a Greek book into Latin,
not to correct it; to draw out another man’s words, not to write
a book of your own. You confess, by the fact of pruning away so much,
that you did not do what you were asked. And I wish that what you
curtailed had all been the bad parts, and that you had not put in many
things of your own which go to support what is bad. I will take an
example, from which men may judge of the rest. In the first book of
the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
where
Origen had uttered that impious blasphemy, that the Son does not see
the Father, you supply the reasons for this, as if in the name of the
writer, and translate the note of Didymus, in which he makes a
fruitless effort to defend another man’s error, trying to prove
that Origen spoke rightly; but we, poor simple men, like the tame
creatures spoken of by Ennius, can understand neither his wisdom nor
that of his translator. Your Preface, which you allege in explanation,
in which you flatter and praise me so highly shows you to be guilty of
the most serious faults of translation. You say that you have cut out
many things from the Greek, but you say nothing of what you have put
in. Were the parts cut out good or bad? Bad, I suppose. Was what you
kept good or bad? Good, I presume; for you could not translate the bad.
Then I suppose you cut off what was bad and left what was good? Of
course. But what you have translated can be shewn to be almost wholly
bad. Whatever therefore in your translation I can shew to be bad, must
be laid to your account, since you translated it as being good. It is a
strange thing if you are to act like an unjust censor, who is himself
guilty of the crime, and are allowed at your will to expel some from
the Senate and keep others in it. But you say: “It was impossible
to change everything. I only thought I might cut away what had been
added by the heretics.” Very good. Then if you cut away all that
you thought had been added by the heretics, all that you left belongs
to the work which you were translating. Answer me then, are these good
or bad? You could not translate what was bad, since once for all you
had cut away what had been added by the heretics, that is, unless you
thought it your duty to cut away the bad parts due to the heretics,
while trans
lating the errors of Origen himself unaltered into Latin. Tell me
then, why you turned Origen’s heresies into Latin. Was it to
expose the author of the evil, or to praise him? If your object is to
expose him, why do you praise him in the Preface? If you praise him you
are convicted of being a heretic. The only remaining hypothesis is that
you published these things as being good. But if they are proved to be
bad, then author and translator are involved in the same crime, and the
Psalmist’s word is fulfilled:
3114
“When
thou sawest a thief, thou consentedst unto him and hast been partaker
with the adulterers.” It is needless to make a plain matter
doubtful by arguing about it. As to what follows, let him answer whence
this suspicion arose in his mind of these additions by heretics.
“It was,” he says, “because I found the same things
treated by this author in other places in a catholic
sense.”
3111
As
above, the word for word rendering is given.
3112
See Rufinus’ position vindicated in his treatise on the
corruption of Origen’s writings, translated in this
volume.
3113
Quin immo etiam,
the first words of
the literally, “Yes, moreover also.”
3114
Ps. l. 18