1223 On Musanus, see chap. 28.
1224 On Modestus, see chap. 25.
1225 Irenæus was born in Asia Minor, probably between the years 120 and 130. There is great uncertainty as
to the date of his birth, some bringing it down almost to the middle of the second century, while Dodwell carried
it back to the year 97 or 98. But these extremes are wild; and a careful examination of all the sources which can
throw any light on the subject leads to the conclusion adopted by Lipsius, and stated above. In Asia Minor he
was a pupil of Polycarp (cf. the fragment of Irenæus’ letter to Florinus, quoted by Eusebius, Bk. V. chap. 20).
The Moscow ms. of the Martyrium Polycarpistates that Irenæus was in Rome at the time of Polycarp’s martyrdom
(155 or 156 a.d.), and appeals for its authority to a statement in Irenæus’ own writings, which does not exist in
any extant work, but may have been taken from an authentic work now lost (cf. Gebhardt, in the Zeitschrift für
die hist. Theologie, 1875, p. 362 sqq.). But whatever truth there may be in the report, we find him, at the time of
the great persecution of Lyons and Vienne (described in the next book, chap. 1), a presbyter of the church at
Lyons, and carrying a letter from the confessors of that church to the bishop Eleutherus of Rome (see Bk. V.
chap. 4). After the death of Pothinus, which took place in 177 (see Bk. V. præf. note 3, and chap. 1, §29), Irenæus
became bishop of Lyons, according to Bk. V. chap. 5. The exact date of his accession we do not know; but as
Pothinus died during the persecution, and Irenæus was still a presbyter after the close of the persecution in
which he met his death, he cannot have succeeded immediately. Since Irenæus, however, was, according to Eu-
sebius, Pothinus’ next successor, no great length of time can have elapsed between the death of the latter and
the accession of the former. At the time of the paschal controversy, while Victor was bishop of Rome, Irenæus
was still bishop (according to Bk. V. chap. 23). This was toward the close of the second century. His death is
ordinarily put in the year 202 or 203, on the assumption that he suffered martyrdom under Septimius Severus.
Jerome is the first to call him a martyr, and that not in his de vir. ill., but in his Comment. in Esaiam (chap. 64),
which was written some years later. It is quite possible that he confounded the Irenæus in question with another
of the same name, who met his death in the persecution of Diocletian. Gregory of Tours first gives us a detailed
account of the martyrdom, and in the Middle Ages Irenæus always figured as a martyr. But all this has no weight
at all, when measured against the silence of Tertullian, Hippolytus, Eusebius, and all the earlier Fathers. Their
silence must be accepted as conclusive evidence that he was not a martyr; and if he was not, there is no reason
for assigning his death to the year 202 or 203. As we have no trace of him, however, subsequent to the time of
the paschal controversy, it is probable that he died, at the latest, soon after the beginning of the third century.
Irenæus was the most important of the polemical writers of antiquity, and his works formed a storehouse from
which all subsequent heresiographers drew. He is quoted very frequently by Eusebius as an authority for events
which happened during the second century, and is treated by him with the most profound respect as one of the
greatest writers of the early Church. Jerome devotes an unusually long chapter of his de vir. ill. to him (chap.
35), but tells us nothing that is not found in Eusebius’ History. His greatest work, and the only one now extant,
is his ῎Ελεγχος καὶ ἀνατροπὴ τῆς ψευδωνύμου γνωσεως, which is commonly cited under the brief title πρὸς
῾Αιρέσεις, or Adversus Hæreses (“Against Heresies”). It consists of five books, and is extant only in a very ancient
and literal Latin translation; though the numerous extracts made from it by later writers have preserved for us
the original Greek of nearly the whole of the first book and many fragments of the others. There are also extant
numerous fragments of an ancient Syriac version of the work. It was written—or at least the third book was—while
446
The Ecclesiastical Writers that flourished in Those Days.