Chapter LIV.
But as in the words which I quoted from Celsus, which are a paraphrase from the
Timæus, certain expressions occur, such as, “God made nothing mortal, but immortal things
alone, while mortal things are the works of others, and the soul is a work of God, but the
nature of the body is different, and there is no difference between the body of a man and
that of a bat, or of a worm, or of a frog; for the matter is the same, and their corruptible part
alike,”—let us discuss these points for a little; and let us show that Celsus either does not
disclose his Epicurean opinions, or, as might be said by one person, has exchanged them
for better, or, as another might say, has nothing in common save the name, with Celsus, the
Epicurean. For he ought, in giving expression to such opinions, and in proposing to contra-
dict not only us, but the by no means obscure sect of philosophers who are the adherents
of Zeno of Citium, to have proved that the bodies of animals are not the work of God, and
that the great skill displayed in their construction did not proceed from the highest intelli-
gence. And he ought also, with regard to the countless diversities of plants, which are regu-
lated by an inherent, incomprehensible nature, 3929 and which have been created for the by
no means despicable 3930 use of man in general, and of the animals which minister to man,
whatever other reasons may be adduced for their existence, 3931 not only to have stated his
opinion, but also to have shown us that it was no perfect intelligence which impressed these
qualities upon the matter of plants. And when he had once represented (various) divinities
as the creators of all the bodies, the soul alone being the work of God, why did not he, who
separated these great acts of creation, and apportioned them among a plurality of creators,
next demonstrate by some convincing reason the existence of these diversities among divin-
ities, some of which construct the bodies of men, and others—those, say, of beasts of burden,
and others—those of wild animals? And he who saw that some divinities were the creators
of dragons, and of asps, and of basilisks, and others of each plant and herb according to its
species, ought to have explained the causes of these diversities. For probably, had he given
himself carefully to the investigation of each particular point, he would either have observed
that it was one God who was the creator of all, and who made each thing with a certain object
and for a certain reason; or if he had failed to observe this, he would have discovered the
answer which he ought to return to those who assert that corruptibility is a thing indifferent
in its nature; and that there was no absurdity in a world which consists of diverse materials,
being formed by one architect, who constructed the different kinds of things so as to secure
the good of the whole. Or, finally, he ought to have expressed no opinion at all on so im-
portant a doctrine, since he did not intend to prove what he professed to demonstrate; unless,
3929 ὑπ᾽ ἐνυπαρχούσης ἀφαντάστου φύσεως διοικουμένων.
3930 πρὸς χρείαν οὐκ εὐκαταφρόνητον.
3931 ὅπως ποτὲ ἄλλως ὄντων.
Chapter LIV
1188
Chapter LIV