Chapter II.
Description of the different heretical monsters which spring from one another.
For these shoots of an unnatural seed are no new thing in the churches. The harvest of
the Lord’s field has always had to put up with burrs and briars, and in it the shoots of
choking tares have constantly sprung up. For hence have arisen the Ebionites, Sabellians,
Arians, as well as Eunomians and Macedonians, and Photinians and Apollinarians, and all
the other tares of the churches, and thistles which destroy the fruits of good faith. And of
these the earliest was Ebion,558 who while over-anxious about asserting our Lord’s human-
ity559 robbed it of its union with Divinity. But after him the schism of Sabellius burst forth
out of reaction against the above mentioned heresy, and as he declared that there was no
distinction between the Father, Son and Holy Ghost, he impiously confounded, as far as
was possible, the Persons, and failed to distinguish the holy and ineffable Trinity. Next after
him whom we have mentioned there followed the blasphemy of Arian perversity, which, in
order to avoid the appearance of confounding the Sacred Persons, declared that there were
552
different and dissimilar substances in the Trinity. But after him in time though like him in
wickedness came Eunomius, who, though allowing that the Persons of the Holy Trinity
were divine and like560 each other, yet insisted that they were separate from each other; and
so while admitting their likeness denied their equality. Macedonius also blaspheming against
the Holy Ghost with unpardonable wickedness, while allowing that the Father and the Son
were of one substance, termed the Holy Ghost a creature, and so sinned against the entire
Divinity, because no injury can be offered to anything in the Trinity without affecting the
entire Trinity. But Photinus, though allowing that Jesus who was born of the Virgin was
God, yet erred in his notion that His Godhead began with the beginning of His manhood;561
while Apollinaris through inaccurately conceiving the union of God and man wrongly be-
lieved that He was without a human soul. For it is as bad an error to add to our Lord Jesus
Christ what does not belong to Him as to rob Him of that which is His. For where He is
spoken of otherwise than as He is—even though it seems to add to His glory—yet it is an
558 The earliest writer to allude to an “Ebion” as the supposed founder of the Ebionites is Tertullian (Præ-
scriptio c. xxxiii.). He is followed in this by Epiphanius (I. xxx.); Rufinus (In Symb. Apost. c. xxxix.), and others;
but the existence of such a person is more than doubtful, and the name is now generally believed to have been
derived from the Hebrew “Ebhion”=poor.
559 Incarnatio.
560 Cassian’s statement here is scarcely accurate, as Eunomius is best known from his bold assertion that the
Son was unlike (ἀνόμοιον) to the Father.
561 Photinus, the pupil of Marcellus of Ancyra, appears to have taught a form of Sabellianism, teaching that
Christ Himself, the Son of God, had not existed from all eternity but only from the time when He became the
Son of God and Christ; viz., at the Incarnation.
Chapter II. Description of the different heretical monsters which spring from one another.
1394
Chapter II. Description of the different heretical monsters which spring…