xxx PROLEGOMENA TO JEROME.
to bring out St. Paul's solution of the question about the Gentile converts, he was manifestly in the wrong, and eventually seems to have felt this, yet as one who was silenced rather
than convinced. At a later period he says to Augustin (Ep. cxxxiv.), "If the heretics see that we hold divergent opinions they will say calumniously that this is a result of hatred,
whereas it is my firm resolution to love you, to look up to you, to defer to you with admira-
tion, and to defend your opinions as my own." His dread of heresy may be gathered from a passage in the Anti-Pelagian Dialogue (i. 28) in which he expressly declares that, while sins
can be forgiven, heresy, as being impiety, is subject to the threat : " They that forsake the
Lord shall be consumed." It is true that in his Catalogue he shows wider sympathies, and defends himself in writing to Augustin for the admission into it of men like Philo Judaeus,
and Seneca. But this, though it might have led him to- the larger views of the heathen world
held by Origen and Clement, did not prevent his condemning to eternal torments even the
most virtuous of the heathen. He tells Marcella, a Roman lady (41-42), that one object he
has in writing to her is to instruct her that the consul-elect Vettius Agorius Praetextatus, who
was known as a model of public and domestic virtue, and who had then recently died, is in
Tartarus, while their friend Lea, who had died the same day, is in heaven.
The lack of deep theological conviction is shown in his Dialogue against the Pelagians,
where it is evident that he is far from that original and deep view of human corruption which
Augustin maintained ; indeed, he appears at times to be arguing against his own side, as
when he says (471) that, "Till the end we are subject to sin ; not," (as the opponent falsely imputes to him) "through the fault of our nature and constitution, but through frailty and
the mutability of the human will, which varies from moment to moment" — a sentence which might be taken as expressing the doctrine of Pelagius himself. It is evident that in these
cases he is swayed not so much by the force of truth as by the authority of certain powerful
Bishops and the wish to maintain his orthodox reputation. In his other controversies, with
Helvidius, Jovinian, John, Bishop of Jerusalem, Vigilantius, and Rufinus, his method is to
take for granted the opinion current among the Christians of his day,, and to support it by
copious (sometimes excessive) quotations from Scripture, and by arguments sometimes well
chosen and acutely maintained, as in the book against Helvidius (339), sometimes of the most
frivolous character, as in that against Vigilantius (422). In the three last of these con-
troversies the opposition is embittered by personal feeling, and Jerome hardly places any
restraint on the contempt and hatred which it engenders.
In his criticisms on Scripture, however, he has a freer judgment, as when he says (337):
" Whether you think that Moses wrote the Pentateuch, or that Ezra re-edited it, in either case
I make no objection ; " or (349) that it was the Book of Deuteronomy which was found in
the Temple in the reign of Josiah ; or contrasts "the flickering flame of the Apostles" with
" the brightness of the lamp of Christ " (468). There are three points especially on which Jerome reached an independent conviction, and maintained it courageously, (i) He made
a clear distinction between the Old Testament Canon and the Apocrypha (194, 491, 492, 493)
and this although he records the fact that the Nicene Council had placed the Book of Judith
in the Canon (494). For this he is justly commemorated in the Articles of the Church of
England (Art. 6). (2) He maintains the essential identity of Bishops and Presbyters (288)
and the development of the Episcopal out of the Presbyteral office (288, 289), in the face of
the rapid tendency to the extreme exaltation of the Episcopate (92). (3) In the greatest
work of his life, the composition of the Vulgate, he showed a clear and matured conviction,
and a noble tenacity, unshaken either by popular clamour (490) or authority like that of
Augustin (189).
A few words may here be said on the asceticism which Jerome so eagerly promoted. If
we ask how it was that he embraced it so fervently as to read it into almost every line of the
Scriptures, we can only answer that it was part of the spirit of the time. Jerome had not the
elevation of mind which might have enabled him to exercise a judgment upon the current
which was bearing him away, or the higher critical power which would distinguish between
what was in the Scriptures and what he brought to them. His habit of mind was to accept
his general principles from some kind of church authority, which was partly that of the
Bishops, partly the general drift of the sentiment of the Christians of his day ; and having
accepted them, to advocate them vehemently and without discrimination. Jerome could
indeed exercise a certain moderation, even in matters of asceticism (246, 267). But his gen-
eral attitude is that which disdained the common joys of life, which thought of eating, drink-
ing, clothing or lodging, and most of all marriage, as physical indulgences which should be
suppressed as far as possible, rather than as the means of a noble social intercourse ; and his
dread of impurity haunts him to such an extent as to entirely vitiate his view of society, and