Chapter VI.—Clement of Alexandria.
Clement1803 having succeeded Pantænus,1804 had charge at that time of the catechetical
instruction in Alexandria, so that Origen also, while still a boy,1805 was one of his pupils.
1803 This chapter has no connection with the preceding, and its insertion at this point has no good ground,
for Clement has been already handled in the fifth book; and if Eusebius wished to refer to him again in connection
with Origen, he should have done so in chap. 3, where Origen’s appointment as head of the catechetical school
is mentioned. (Redepenning, however, approves the present order; vol. I. p. 431 sqq.) Rufinus felt the inconsist-
ency, and hence inserted chaps. 6 and 7 in the middle of chap. 3, where the account of Origen’s appointment
by Demetrius is given. Valesius considers the occurrence of this mention of Clement at this point a sign that
Eusebius did not give his work a final revision. Chap. 13 is inserted in the same abrupt way, quite out of harmony
with the context. Upon the life of Clement of Alexandria, see Bk. V. chap. 11, note 1. The catechetical school
was vacant, as we learn from chap. 2, in the year 203, and was then taken in charge by Origen, so that the “that
time” referred to by Eusebius in this sentence must be carried back of the events related in the previous chapters.
The cause of Clement’s leaving the school was probably the persecution begun by Severus in 202 (“all were
driven away by the threatening aspect of persecution,” according to chap. 3, §1); for since Origen was one of his
pupils he can hardly have left long before that time. That it was not unworthy cowardice which led Clement to
take his departure is clear enough from the words of Alexander in chaps. 11 and 14, from the high reputation
which he continued to enjoy throughout the Church, and from his own utterances on the subject of martyrdom
scattered through his works.
1804 On Pantænus, see Bk. V. chap. 10, note 2.
1805 Stephanus, Stroth, Burton, Schwegler, Laemmer, and Heinichen, following two important mss. and the
translation of Rufinus, omit the words παῖδα ὄντα “while a boy.” But the words are found in all the other codices
(the chief witnesses of two of the three great families of mss. being for them) and in Nicephorus. The manuscript
authority is therefore overwhelmingly in favor of the words, and they are adopted by Valesius, Zimmermann,
and Crusè. Rufinus is a strong witness against the words but, as Redepenning justly remarks, having inserted
this chapter, as he did, in the midst of the description of Origen’s early years (see note 1), the words παῖδα ὄντα
would be quite superfluous and even out of place, and hence he would naturally omit them. So far as the prob-
abilities of the insertion or omission of the words in the present passage are concerned, it seems to me more
natural to suppose that a copyist, finding the words at this late stage in the account of Origen’s life, would be
inclined to omit them, than that not finding them there he should, upon historical grounds (which he could
have reached only after some reflection), think that they ought to be inserted. The latter would be not only a
more difficult but also a much graver step than the former. There seems, then, to be no good warrant for omitting
these words. We learn from chap. 3 that he took charge of the catechetical school when he was in his eighteenth
year, within a year therefore after the death of his father. And we learn that before he took charge of the school,
all who had given instruction there had been driven away by the persecution. Clement, therefore, must have left
before Origen’s eighteenth year, and hence the latter must have studied with him before the persecution had
broken up the school, and in all probability before the death of Leonides. In any case, therefore, he was still a
boy when under Clement, and even if we omit the words—“while a boy”—here, we shall not be warranted in
Clement of Alexandria.
613
Clement of Alexandria.