Chapter 5.—That It is Especially with the Platonists that We Must Carry on Our Dispu-
tations on Matters of Theology, Their Opinions Being Preferable to Those of All Other
Philosophers.
If, then, Plato defined the wise man as one who imitates, knows, loves this God, and
who is rendered blessed through fellowship with Him in His own blessedness, why discuss
with the other philosophers? It is evident that none come nearer to us than the Platonists.
To them, therefore, let that fabulous theology give place which delights the minds of men
with the crimes of the gods; and that civil theology also, in which impure demons, under
the name of gods, have seduced the peoples of the earth given up to earthly pleasures, desiring
to be honored by the errors of men, and by filling the minds of their worshippers with impure
desires, exciting them to make the representation of their crimes one of the rites of their
worship, whilst they themselves found in the spectators of these exhibitions a most pleasing
spectacle,—a theology in which, whatever was honorable in the temple, was defiled by its
mixture with the obscenity of the theatre, and whatever was base in the theatre was vindicated
by the abominations of the temples. To these philosophers also the interpretations of Varro
must give place, in which he explains the sacred rites as having reference to heaven and
earth, and to the seeds and operations of perishable things; for, in the first place, those rites
have not the signification which he would have men believe is attached to them, and therefore
truth does not follow him in his attempt so to interpret them; and even if they had this sig-
nification, still those things ought not to be worshipped by the rational soul as its god which
are placed below it in the scale of nature, nor ought the soul to prefer to itself as gods things
to which the true God has given it the preference. The same must be said of those writings
pertaining to the sacred rites, which Numa Pompilius took care to conceal by causing them
to be buried along with himself, and which, when they were afterwards turned up by the
plough, were burned by order of the senate. And, to treat Numa with all honor, let us
mention as belonging to the same rank as these writings that which Alexander of Macedon
wrote to his mother as communicated to him by Leo, an Egyptian high priest. In this letter
not only Picus and Faunus, and Æneas and Romulus or even Hercules, and Æsculapius and
Liber, born of Semele, and the twin sons of Tyndareus, or any other mortals who have been
deified, but even the principal gods themselves,299 to whom Cicero, in his Tusculan ques-
tions,300 alludes without mentioning their names, Jupiter, Juno, Saturn, Vulcan, Vesta, and
many others whom Varro attempts to identify with the parts or the elements of the world,
299 Dii majorum gentium.
300 Book i. 13.
That It is Especially with the Platonists that We Must Carry on Our Disputations on Matters of Theology, Their Opinions Being Preferable to Those of All Other Philosophers.
342
That It is Especially with the Platonists that We Must Carry on Our Disputations…