5. Five Books
in Reply to Marcion.
(Author Uncertain.)
Book I.—Of the Divine Unity, and
the Resurrection of the Flesh.
Part I.—Of the Divine
Unity.
After
the Evil One’s
impiety
Profound, and his life-grudging mind, entrapped
Seducèd men with empty hope, it laid
Them bare, by impious suasion to false trust
5 In him,—not with impunity, indeed;
For he forthwith, as guilty of the deed,
And author rash of such a wickedness,
Received deserved maledictions. Thus,
Thereafter, maddened, he, most desperate foe,
10 Did more assail and instigate men’s
minds
In darkness sunk. He taught them to forget
The Lord, and leave sure hope, and idols vain
Follow, and shape themselves a crowd of gods,
Lots, auguries, false names of stars, the show
15 Of being able to o’errule the births
Of embryos by inspecting entrails, and
Expecting things to come, by hardihood
Of dreadful magic’s renegadoes led,
Wondering at a mass of feigned lore;
20 And he impelled them headlong to spurn
life,
Sunk in a criminal insanity;
To joy in blood; to threaten murders fell;
To love the wound, then, in their neighbour’s
flesh;
Or, burning, and by pleasure’s heat entrapped,
25 To transgress nature’s covenants, and
stain
Pure bodies, manly sex, with an embrace
Unnameable, and uses feminine
Mingled in common contact lawlessly;
Urging embraces chaste, and dedicate
30 To generative duties, to be held
For intercourse obscene for passion’s sake.
Such in time past his deeds, assaulting men,
Through the soul’s lurking-places, with a flow
Of scorpion-venom,—not that men would blame
35 Him, for they followed of their own accord:
His suasion was in guile; in freedom man
Performed it.
Whileas the perfidious one
Continuously through the centuries
1345
Is breathing such ill fumes, and into hearts
40 Seduced injecting his own counselling
And hoping in his folly (alas!) to find
Forgiveness of his wickedness, unware
What sentence on his deed is waiting him;
With words of wisdom’s weaving,
1346
and a voice
45 Presaging from God’s Spirit, speak a
host
Of prophets. Publicly he
1347
does not dare
Nakedly to speak evil of the Lord,
Hoping by secret ingenuity
He possibly may lurk unseen. At length
50 The soul’s Light
1348
as the thrall of flesh is held;
The hope of the despairing, mightier
Than foe, enters the lists; the Fashioner,
The Renovator, of the body He;
True Glory of the Father; Son of God;
55 Author unique; a Judge and Lord He came,
The orb’s renowned King; to the opprest
Prompt to give pardon, and to loose the bound;
Whose friendly aid and penal suffering
Blend God and renewed man in one. With child
60 Is holy virgin: life’s new gate
opes; words
Of prophets find their proof, fulfilled by facts;
Priests
1349
leave their
temples, and—a star their guide—
Wonder the Lord so mean a birth should choose.
Waters—sight memorable!—turn to wine;
65 Eyes are restored to blind; fiends trembling
cry,
Outdriven by His bidding, and own Christ!
All limbs, already rotting, by a word
Are healed; now walks the lame; the deaf forthwith
Hears hope; the maimed extends his hand; the dumb
70 Speaks mighty words: sea at His bidding
calms,
Winds drop; and all things recognise the Lord:
Confounded is the foe, and yields, though fierce,
Now triumphed over, to unequal
1350
arms!
When all his enterprises now revoked
75 He
1351
sees; the
flesh, once into ruin sunk,
Now rising;
man—death vanquisht quite—to heavens
Soaring; the peoples sealed with holy pledge
Outpoured;
1352
the work and
envied deeds of might
Marvellous;
1353
and hears,
too, of penalties
80 Extreme, and of perpetual dark, prepared
For himself by the Lord by God’s decree
Irrevocable; naked and unarmed,
Damned, vanquisht, doomed to perish in a death
Perennial, guilty now, and sure that he
85 No pardon has, a last impiety
Forthwith he dares,—to scatter everywhere
A word for ears to shudder at, nor meet
For voice to speak. Accosting men cast off
From God’s community,
1354
men wandering
90 Without the light, found mindless,
following
Things earthly, them he teaches to become
Depraved teachers of depravity.
By
1355
them he preaches
that there are two Sires,
And realms divided: ill’s cause is the
Lord
1356
95 Who built the orb, fashioned breath-quickened
flesh,
And gave the law, and by the seers’ voice
spake.
Him he affirms not
good
, but owns Him
just
;
Hard, cruel, taking pleasure fell in war;
In judgment dreadful, pliant to no prayers.
100 His suasion tells of other one, to none
E’er known, who nowhere is, a deity
False, nameless, constituting nought, and who
Hath spoken precepts none. Him he calls
good
;
Who judges none, but spares all equally,
105 And grudges life to none. No judgment
waits
The guilty; so he says, bearing about
A gory poison with sweet honey mixt
For wretched men. That flesh can rise—to
which
Himself was cause of ruin, which he spoiled
110 Iniquitously with contempt
(whence,
1357
cursed,
He hath grief without end), its ever-foe,—
He doth deny; because with various wound
Life to expel and the salvation whence
He fell he strives: and therefore says that
Christ
115 Came suddenly to earth,
1358
but was not made,
By any compact, partner of the flesh;
But Spirit-form, and body feigned beneath
A shape imaginary, seeks to mock
Men with a semblance that what is not is.
120 Does this, then, become God, to sport with
men
By darkness led? to act an impious lie?
Or falsely call Himself a man? He walks,
Is carried, clothed, takes due rest, handled is,
Suffers, is hung and buried: man’s are
all
125 Deeds which, in holy body conversant,
But sent by God the Father, who hath all
Created, He did perfect properly,
Reclaiming not another’s but His own;
Discernible to peoples who of old
130 Were hoping for Him by His very work,
And through the prophets’ voice to the round
world
1359
Best known: and now they seek an unknown Lord,
Wandering in death’s threshold manifest,
And leave behind the known. False is their
faith,
135 False is their God, deceptive their
reward,
False is their resurrection, death’s defeat
False, vain their martyrdoms, and e’en
Christ’s name
An empty sound: whom, teaching that He came
Like magic mist, they (quite demented) own
140 To be the actor of a lie, and make
His passion bootless, and the populace
1360
(A feigned one!) without crime! Is God
thus
true?
Are
such
the honours rendered to the
Lord?
Ah! wretched men! gratuitously lost
145 In death ungrateful! Who, by blind guide
led,
Have headlong rushed into the ditch!
1361
and as
In dreams the fancied rich man in his store
Of treasure doth exult, and with his hands
Grasps it, the sport of empty hope, so ye, so
150 Deceived, are hoping for a shadow vain
Of guerdon!
Ah! ye silent laughingstocks,
Or doomed prey, of the dragon, do ye hope,
Stern men, for
death in room of gentle peace?
1362
Dare ye blame
God
, who hath
works
155 So great? in whose earth, ’mid profuse
displays
Of His exceeding parent-care, His gifts
(Unmindful of Himself!) ye largely praise,
Rushing to ruin! do ye reprobate—
Approving of the works—the Maker’s self,
160 The world’s
1363
Artificer, whose work withal
Ye are yourselves? Who gave those little
selves
Great honours; sowed your crops; made all the
brutes
1364
Your subjects; makes the seasons of the year
Fruitful with stated months; grants sweetnesses,
165 Drinks various, rich odours, jocund
flowers,
And the groves’ grateful bowers; to growing
herbs
Grants wondrous juices; founts and streams dispreads
With sweet waves, and illumes with stars the sky
And the whole orb: the infinite sole
Lord
,
170 Both
Just
and
Good
; known by His work; to none
By aspect known; whom nations, flourishing
In wealth, but foolish, wrapped in error’s
shroud,
(Albeit ’tis beneath an alien name
They praise Him, yet) their Maker knowing! dread
175 To blame: nor e’en
one
1365
—save you, hell’s new
gate!—
Thankless, ye choose to speak ill of your Lord!
These cruel deadly gifts the Renegade
Terrible has bestowed, through Marcion—thanks
To Cerdo’s mastership—on you; nor comes
180 The thought into your mind that, from
Christ’s name
Seduced, Marcion’s name has carried you
To lowest depths.
1366
Say of His many acts
What one displeases you? or what hath God
Done which is not to be extolled with praise?
185 Is it that He permits you, all too long,
(Unworthy of His patience large,) to see
Sweet light? you, who read truths,
1367
and, docking them,
Teach these your falsehoods, and approve as past
Things which are yet to be?
1368
What hinders, else,
190 That
we
believe
your
God
incredible?
1369
Nor marvel is’t if, practiced as he
1370
is,
He captived you unarmed, persuading you
There are two Fathers (being damned by One),
And all, whom he had erst seduced, are gods;
195 And after that dispread a pest, which ran
With multiplying wound, and cureless crime,
To many. Men unworthy to be named,
Full of all magic’s madness, he induced
To call themselves “Virtue Supreme;” and
feign
200 (With harlot comrade) fresh impiety;
To roam, to fly.
1371
He is the insane god
Of Valentine, and to his Æonage
Assigned heavens thirty, and Profundity
Their sire.
1372
He
taught two baptisms, and led
205 The body through the flame. That there
are gods
So many as the year hath days, he bade
A Basilides to believe, and worlds
As many. Marcus, shrewdly arguing
Through numbers, taught to violate chaste form
210 ’Mid magic’s arts; taught, too,
that the Lord’s cup
Is an oblation, and by prayers is turned
To blood. His
1373
suasion prompted Hebion
To teach that Christ was born from human seed;
He taught, too,
circumcision, and that room
215 Is still left for the Law, and, though
Law’s founts
Are lost,
1374
its elements must
be resumed.
Unwilling am I to protract in words
His last atrocity, or to tell all
The causes, or the names at length. Enough
220 It is to note his many cruelties
Briefly, and the unmentionable men,
The dragon’s organs fell, through whom he now,
Speaking so much profaneness, ever toils
To blame the Maker of the world.
1375
But come;
225 Recall your foot from savage Bandit’s
cave,
While space is granted, and to wretched men
God, patient in perennial parent-love,
Condones all deeds through error done! Believe
Truly in the true
Sire
, who
built the orb;
230 Who, on behalf of men incapable
To bear the law, sunk in sin’s whirlpool, sent
The true
Lord
to repair the ruin
wrought,
And bring them the salvation promised
Of old through seers. He who the mandates gave
235 Remits sins too. Somewhat,
deservedly,
Doth He exact, because He formerly
Entrusted somewhat; or else bounteously,
As Lord, condones as it were debts to slaves:
Finally, peoples shut up ’neath the curse,
240 And meriting the penalty, Himself
Deleting the indictment, bids be washed!
Part II.—Of the Resurrection of
the Flesh.
The
whole
man, then, believes; the
whole
is washed;
Abstains from sin, or truly suffers wounds
For Christ’s name’s sake: he
rises a true
1376
man,
245 Death, truly vanquish, shall be mute.
But not
Part of the man,—his
soul
,—her
own part
1377
left
Behind, will win the palm which, labouring
And wrestling in the course, combinedly
And simultaneously with
flesh
, she
earns.
250 Great crime it were for two in chains to
bear
A weight, of whom the one were affluent
The other needy, and the wretched one
Be spurned, and guerdons to the happy one
Rendered. Not so the Just—fair Renderer
255 Of wages—deals, both good and just, whom
we
Believe Almighty: to the thankless kind
Full is His will of pity. Nay, whate’er
He who hath greater mortal need
1378
doth need
1379
That, by advancement, to his comrade he
260 May equalled be, that will the affluent
Bestow the rather unsolicited:
So are we bidden to believe, and not
Be willing to cast blame unlawfully
On the Lord in our teaching, as if He
265 Were one to raise the
soul
, as
having met
With ruin, and to set her free from death
So that the granted faculty of life
Upon the ground of sole desert (because
She bravely acted), should abide with
her;
1380
270 While she who ever shared the common lot
Of toil, the
flesh
, should to the earth be
left,
The prey of a perennial death. Has, then,
The
soul
pleased God by acts of
fortitude?
By no means could she Him have pleased alone
275 Without the
flesh
. Hath she
borne penal bonds?
1381
The flesh sustained upon her limbs the bonds.
Contemned she death? But she hath left the
flesh
Behind in death. Groaned she in
pain?
The
flesh
is slain and vanquisht by the
wound. Repose
280 Seeks she? The
flesh
, spilt
by the sword in dust,
Is left behind to fishes, birds, decay,
And ashes; torn she is, unhappy one!
And broken; scattered, she melts away.
Hath she not earned to rise? for what could she
285 Have e’er committed, lifeless and
alone?
What so life-grudging
1382
cause impedes, or else
Forbids, the
flesh
to take God’s
gifts, and live
Ever, conjoined with her comrade
soul
,
And see what she hath been, when formerly
290 Converted into dust?
1383
After, renewed,
Bear she to God deserved meeds of praise,
Not ignorant of herself, frail, mortal,
sick.
1384
Contend ye as to what the living might
1385
Of the great God can
do; who, good alike
295 And potent, grudges life to none? Was
this
Death’s captive?
1386
shall this perish vanquished
Which the Lord hath with wondrous wisdom made,
And art? This by His virtue wonderful
Himself upraises; this our Leader’s self
300 Recalls, and this with His own glory
clothes
God’s art and wisdom, then, our body shaped
What can by these be made, how faileth it
To be by virtue reproduced?
1387
No cause
Can holy parent-love withstand; (lest else
305 Ill’s cause
1388
should mightier prove than Power
Supreme;)
That man even now saved by God’s gift, may
learn
1389
(Mortal before, now robed in light immense
Inviolable, wholly quickened,
1390
soul
And body) God, in virtue infinite,
310 In parent-love perennial, through His King
Christ, through whom opened is light’s way; and
now,
Standing in new light, filled now with each
gift,
1391
Glad with fair fruits of living Paradise,
May praise and laud Him to eternity,
1392
315 Rich in the wealth of the celestial
hall.
1345
Sæcula.
1346
The
“tectis” of the edd. I have ventured to alter to
“textis,” which gives (as in my text) a far better
sense.
1347
i.e., the Evil
One.
1348
i.e., the Son of
God.
1349
i.e., the Magi.
1350
i.e., arms which
seemed
unequal; for the cross, in which Christ
seemed
to
be vanquished, was the very means of His triumph. See
Col. ii. 14, 15
.
1351
i.e., the Enemy.
1352
i.e., with the Holy
Spirit, the “Pledge” or “Promise” of the Father
(see
Acts i. 4, 5
), “outpoured” upon
“the peoples”—both Jewish and Gentile—on the
day of Pentecost and many subsequent occasions; see, for instances,
Acts x. and xix
.
1353
The
“mirandæ virtutis opus, invisaque facts,” I take to be
the miracles wrought by the apostles through the might (virtus) of the
Spirit, as we read in the Acts. These were objects of
“envy” to the Enemy, and to such as—like Simon Magus,
of whom we find record—were his servants.
1354
i.e., excommunicated,
as Marcion was. The “last impiety” (
extremum
nefas
), or “last atrocity” (
extremum
facinus
),—see 218, lower down—seems to mean the
introduction of
heretical teaching
.
1355
This use of the
ablative, though quite against classical usage, is apparently
admissible in late Latinity. It seems to me that the
“his”
is
an ablative here, the men being regarded
for the moment as merely
instruments
, not
agents
; but it
may
be a dative ="
to
these he preaches,” etc.,
i.e., he dictates
to
them what they afterwards are to teach in
public.
1356
It must be borne in
mind that “Dominus” (the Lord), and “Deus”
(God), are kept as distinct terms throughout this piece.
1357
i.e., for which
reason.
1358
i.e., as Marcion is
stated by some to have taught, in the fifteenth year of Tiberius;
founding his statement upon a perverted reading of
Luke iii. 1
. It will be remembered that
Marcion only used St. Luke’s Gospel, and that in a mutilated and
corrupted form.
1359
Orbi.
1360
i.e., of the Jews.
1361
“In
fossa,” i.e., as Fabricius (quoted in Migne’s ed.) explains
it, “in
de
fossa.” It is the past part. of
fodio
.
1362
If this line be
correct,—“Speratis pro pace truces homicidia
blanda,”—though I cannot see the propriety of the
“truces” in it, it seems to mean, “Do ye hope or
expect that the master you are serving will, instead of the gentle
peace he promises you, prove a murderer and lead you to death?
No, you do not expect it; but so it is.”
1363
Mundi.
1364
Animalia.
1365
The sentence breaks
off abruptly, and the verb which should apparently have gone with
“e’en one” is joined to the “ye” in the
next line.
1366
The Latin is:—
“Nec venit in mentem quod vos, a nomine
Christi
Seductos, ad Marcionis tulit infima
nomen.”
The rendering in my text, I admit, involves
an exceedingly harsh construction of the Latin, but I see not how it is
to be avoided; unless either (1) we take
nomen
absolutely, and
“ad Marcionis infima” together, and translate, “A
name has carried you to Marcion’s lowest depths;” in which
case the question arises, What name is meant? can it be the name
“Electi”? Or else (2) we take “tulit” as
referring to the “terrible renegade,” i.e., the arch-fiend,
and “infima” as in apposition with “ad Marcionis
nomen,” and translate, “He has carried you to the name of
Marcion—deepest degradation.”
1367
i.e., the Gospels and
other parts of Holy Scripture.
1368
i.e., I take it, the
resurrection. Cf.
2 Tim.
ii. 17, 18
.
1369
Whether this be
the sense (i.e., “either tell us what it is which displeases you
in
our
God, whether it be His too great patience in bearing with
you, or what; or else tell us what is to hinder
us
from
believing
your
God to be an
incredible
being”) of
this passage, I will not venture to determine. The last line in
the edd. previous to Oehler’s ran: “Aut
incredibil
e
quid differt credere vestrum?”
Oehler reads “incredibil
em
” (sc. Deum),
which I have followed; but he suggests, “Aut
incredibil
em qui
differt
cædere
vestrum?” Which may mean “or
else”—i.e., if it were not for his “too great
patience”—“why”—“qui”—“does
He delay to smite your incredible god?” and thus challenge a
contest and prove His own superiority.
1370
i.e., the
“terrible renegade.”
1371
The reference here is
to Simon Magus; for a brief account of whom, and of the other heretics
in this list, down to Hebion inclusive, the reader is referred to the
Adv. omn. Hær.
, above. The words “to roam, to
fly,” refer to the alleged wanderings of Simon with his paramour
Helen, and his reported attempt (at Rome, in the presence of St. Peter)
to fly. The tale is doubtful.
1372
The Latin runs thus:—
“Et ævo
Triginta tribuit cælos, patremque
Profundum.”
But there seems a confusion between Valentine
and his æons and Basilides and his heavens. See the
Adv.
omn. Hær
., above.
1373
i.e., the Evil
One’s, as before.
1374
i.e., probably
Jerusalem and the temple there.
1375
Mundi.
1376
Oehler’s
“versus” (="changed the man rises”) is set aside for
Migne’s “verus.” Indeed it is probably a
misprint.
1377
i.e., her own dwelling
or “quarters,”—the body, to wit, if the reading
“sua parte” be correct.
1378
Egestas.
1379
Eget.
1380
I have ventured to
alter the “
e
t viven
ti
” of Oehler
and Migne into “
u
t viven
di
,”
which seems to improve the sense.
1381
It seems to me that
these ideas should all be expressed interrogatively, and I have
therefore so expressed them in my text.
1382
See line 2.
1383
“Cernere quid
fuerit conversa in pulvere quondam.”
Whether the meaning be that, as the
soul
will be able (as it should seem) to retrace all that she
has experienced since she left the body, so the
body
, when
revived, will be able as it were to look back upon all that has
happened to her since the soul left her,—something after the
manner in which Hamlet traces the imaginary vicissitudes of
Cæsar’s dust,—or whether there be some great error in
the Latin, I leave the reader to judge.
1384
i.e., apparently
remembering that she
was
so
before
.
1385
Vivida virtus.
1386
I rather incline to read for
“hæc captiva fu
it
mortis,”
“hæc captiva fu
at
mortis” =
“Is this
To be death’s thrall?”
“This” is, of course, the
flesh.
1387
For “Quod
c
u
pit his fieri, deest hoc virtute reduci,” I
venture to read, “Quod c
a
pit,” etc.,
taking “capit” as ="capax est.” “By
these,” of course, is by wisdom and art; and “virtue”
="power.”
1388
i.e., the Evil
One.
1389
i.e., may learn
to know.
1390
Oehler’s
“vi
s
us” seems to be a mistake for
“vi
v
us,” which is Migne’s
reading; as in the fragment “
De exsecrandis gentium
diis,
” we saw (
sub. fin
.)
“vi
d
entem” to be a probable misprint
for “vi
v
entem.” If, however, it
is to be retained, it must mean “appearing” (i.e., in
presence of God) “wholly,” in body as well as soul.
1391
i.e., the double gift
of a saved soul and a saved body.
1392
In æternum.