“these being so, and maintaining an unbroken connexion in their relation to one another.”
It is equal madness to say such things, and to hear them without any questioning. They are
placed in a ‘series’ and ‘an unalterable relation to each other,’ and yet they are parted from
each other by an essential unlikeness! Either, as our own doctrine insists, they are united in
being, and then they really preserve an unalterable relation to each other; or else they stand
apart in essential unlikeness, as he fancies. But what series, what relationship that is unalter-
able can exist with alien entities? And how can they present that ‘order germane to the
matter’ which according to him is to rule the investigation? Now if he had an eye only on
the doctrine of the truth, and if the order in which he counts the differences was only that
of the attributes which Faith sees in the Holy Trinity,—an order so ‘natural’ and ‘germane’
that the Persons cannot be confounded, being divided as Persons, though united in their
being—then he would not have been classed at all amongst our enemies, for he would mean
the very same doctrine that we teach. But, as it is, he is looking in the very contrary direction,
and he makes the order which he fancies there quite inconceivable. There is all the difference
in the world between the accomplishment of an act of the will, and that of a mechanical law
of nature. Heat is inherent in fire, splendour in the sunbeam, fluidity in water, downward
tendency in a stone, and so on. But if a man builds a house, or seeks an office, or puts to sea
with a cargo, or attempts anything else which requires forethought and preparation to suc-
ceed, we cannot say in such a case that there is properly a rank or order inherent in his op-
erations: their order in each case will result as an after consequence of the motive which
guided his choice, or the utility of that which he achieves. Well, then; since this heresy parts
the Son from any essential relationship with the Father, and adopts the same view of the
Spirit as estranged from any union with the Father or the Son, and since also it affirms
throughout that the Son is the work of the Father, and the Spirit the work of the Son, and
that these works are the results of a purpose, not of nature, what grounds has he for declaring
that this work of a will is an ‘order inherent in the matter,’ and what is the drift of this
teaching, which makes the Almighty the manufacturer of such a nature as this in the Son
and the Holy Spirit, where transcendent beings are made such as to be inferior the one to
the other? If such is really his meaning, why did he not clearly state the grounds he has for
presuming in the case of the Deity, that smallness of result will be evidence of all the greater
power? But who really could ever allow that a cause that is great and powerful is to be looked
for in this smallness of results? As if God was unable to establish His own perfection in
74
anything that comes from Him161! And how can he attribute to the Deity the highest
prerogative of supremacy while he exhibits His power as thus falling short of His will? Eun-
omius certainly seems to mean that perfection was not even proposed as the aim of God’s
work, for fear the honour and glory of One to Whom homage is due for His superiority
161 ἐν παντὶ τῷ ἐξ αὐτοῦ.
139
He falsely imagines that we can have an unalterable series of harmonious…