Scripture, which were both sent before in prophecy and fully expounded by apostolical in-
terpretation: “Thou wilt not leave my soul in hell.”2681
9. I know that some think that at the death of Christ a resurrection such as is promised
to us at the end of the world was granted to the righteous, founding this on the statement
in Scripture that, in the earthquake by which at the moment of His death the rocks were
rent and the graves were opened, many bodies of the saints arose and were seen with Him
in the Holy City after He rose. Certainly, if these did not fall asleep again, their bodies being
a second time laid in the grave, it would be necessary to see in what sense Christ can be
understood to be “the first begotten from the dead,”2682 if so many preceded Him in the
resurrection. And if it be said, in answer to this, that the statement is made by anticipation,
so that the graves indeed are to be supposed to have been opened by that earthquake at the
time when Christ was hanging on the cross, but that the bodies of the saints did not rise
then, but only after Christ had risen before them,—although on this hypothesis of anticipation
in the narrative, the addition of these words would not hinder us from still believing, on the
one hand, that Christ was without doubt “the first begotten from the dead,” and on the
other, that to these saints permission was given, when He went before them, to rise to an
eternal state of incorruption and immortality, there still remains a difficulty, namely, how
in that case Peter could have spoken as he did, saying what was without doubt perfectly true,
when he affirmed that in the prophecy quoted above the words, that “His flesh should not
see corruption,” referred not to David but to Christ, and added concerning David, “He is
buried, and his sepulchre is with us to this day,”2683—a statement which would have had
no force as an argument unless the body of David was still undisturbed in the sepulchre;
for of course the sepulchre might still have been there even had the saint’s body been raised
up immediately after his death, and had thus not seen corruption. But it seems hard that
518
David should not be included in this resurrection of the saints, if eternal life was given to
them, since it is so frequently, so clearly, and with such honourable mention of his name,
declared that Christ was to be of David’s seed. Moreover, these words in the Epistle to the
Hebrews concerning the ancient believers, “God having provided some better thing for us,
that they without us should not be made perfect,”2684 will be endangered, if these believers
have been already established in that incorruptible resurrection-state which is promised to
us when we are to be made perfect at the end of the world.
Chap. IV.
2681 Ps. xvi. 10.
2682 Rev. i. 5.
2683 Acts ii. 28.
2684 Heb. xi. 40.
1104
To Evodius