Chapter II.
The assertion of the Novatians that they refuse communion only to the lapsed agrees
neither with the teaching of holy Scripture nor with their own. And whereas they allege as a
330
pretext their reverence for the divine power, they really are contemning it, inasmuch as it is
a sign of low estimation not to use the whole of a power entrusted to one. But the Church
rightly claims the power of binding and loosing, which heretics have not, inasmuch as she has
received it from the Holy Spirit, against Whom they act presumptuously.
5. But they say that those should not be restored to communion who have fallen into
denial2137 of the faith. If they made the crime of sacrilege the only exception to receiving
forgiveness, they would be acting harshly indeed, and, as it would seem, would be in oppos-
ition to the divine utterances only, while consistent with their own assertions. For when the
Lord forgave all sins, He made an exception of none. But since, as it were after the fashion
of the Stoics, they think that all sins are equal in gravity, and assert that he who has stolen
a common fowl, as they say, no less than he who has smothered his father, should be for
ever excluded from the divine mysteries, how can they select those guilty of one special of-
fence, since even they themselves cannot deny that it is most unjust that the penalty of one
should extend to many?2138
6. They affirm that they are showing great reverence for God, to Whom alone they reserve
the power of forgiving sins. But in truth none do Him greater injury than they who choose
to prune His commandments and reject the office entrusted to them. For inasmuch as the
Lord Jesus Himself said in the Gospel: “Receive ye the Holy Spirit: whosesoever sins ye forgive
they are forgiven unto them, and whosesoever sins ye retain, they are retained,”2139 who is
it that honours Him most, he who obeys His bidding or he who rejects it?
7. The Church holds fast its obedience on either side, by both retaining and remitting
sin; heresy is on the one side cruel, and on the other disobedient; wishes to bind what it will
not loosen, and will not loosen what it has bound, whereby it condemns itself by its own
sentence. For the Lord willed that the power of binding and of loosing should be alike, and
sanctioned each by a similar condition. So he who has not the power to loose has not the
power to bind. For as, according to the Lord’s word, he who has the power to bind has also
the power to loose, their teaching destroys itself, inasmuch as they who deny that they have
the power of loosing ought also to deny that of binding. For how can the one be allowed
and the other disallowed? It is plain and evident that either each is allowed or each is disal-
lowed in the case of those to whom each has been given. Each is allowed to the Church,
neither to heresy, for this power has been entrusted to priests alone. Rightly, therefore, does
2137 Prævaricatio.
2138 i.e. the penalty of the one sin of denying the faith should be extended to all sins.
2139 S. John xx. 22, 23.
Chapter II. The assertion of the Novatians that they refuse communion only to the lapsed agrees neither with the teaching of holy Scripture nor with their own. And whereas they allege as a pretext their reverence for the divine power, they really are contemning it, inasmuch as it is a sign of low estimation not to use the whole of a power entrusted to one. But the Church rightly claims the power of binding and loosing, which heretics have not, inasmuch as she has received it from the Holy Spirit, against Whom they act presumptuously.
723
Chapter II. The assertion of the Novatians that they refuse communion only…