Chapter II
The Writings of
Eusebius.
§1.
Eusebius as a Writer
Eusebius
was one of the most voluminous writers of antiquity, and his
labors covered almost every field of theological learning. In the words
of Lightfoot he was “historian, apologist, topographer, exegete,
critic, preacher, dogmatic writer, in turn.” It is as an
historian that he is best known, but the importance of his historical
writings should not cause us to overlook, as modern scholars have been
prone to do, his invaluable productions in other departments. Lightfoot
passes a very just judgment upon the importance of his works in the
following words: “If the permanent utility of an author’s
labors may be taken as a test of literary excellence, Eusebius will
hold a very high place indeed. The
Ecclesiastical History
is
absolutely unique and indispensable. The
Chronicle
is the vast
storehouse of information relating to the ancient monarchies of the
world. The
Preparation
and
Demonstration
are the most
important contributions to theology in their own province. Even the
minor works, such as the
Martyrs of Palestine
, the
Life of
Constantine,
the
Questions addressed to Stephanus and to
Marinus
, and others, would leave an irreparable blank, if they were
obliterated. And the same permanent value attaches also to his more
technical treatises. The
Canons
and
Sections
have never
yet been superseded for their particular purpose. The
Topography of
Palestine
is the most important contribution to our knowledge in
its own department. In short, no ancient ecclesiastical writer has laid
posterity under heavier obligations.”
If we look in Eusebius’
works for evidences of brilliant genius we shall be disappointed. He
did not possess a great creative mind like Origen’s or
Augustine’s. His claim to greatness rests upon his vast erudition
and his sterling sense. His powers of acquisition were remarkable and
his diligence in study unwearied. He had at his command undoubtedly
more acquired material than any man of his age, and he possessed that
true literary and historical instinct which enabled him to select from
his vast stores of knowledge those things which it was most worth his
while to tell to the world. His writings therefore remain valuable
while the works of many others, perhaps no less richly equipped than
himself for the mission of adding to the sum of human knowledge, are
entirely forgotten. He thus had the ability to do more than acquire; he
had the ability to impart to others the very best of that which he
acquired, and to make it useful to them. There is not in his writings
the brilliancy which we find in some others, there is not the same
sparkle and freshness of new and suggestive thought, there is not the
same impress of an overmastering individuality which transforms
everything it touches. There is, however, a true and solid merit which
marks his works almost without exception, and raises them above the
commonplace. His exegesis is superior to that of most of his
contemporaries, and his apologetics is marked by fairness of statement,
breadth of treatment, and instinctive appreciation of the difference
between the important and the unimportant points under discussion,
which give to his apologetic works a
permanent value. His wide
acquaintance, too, with other systems than his own, and with the
products of Pagan as well as Christian thought, enabled him to see
things in their proper relations and to furnish a treatment of the
great themes of Christianity adapted to the wants of those who had
looked beyond the confines of a single school. At the same time it must
be acknowledged that he was not always equal to the grand opportunities
which his acquaintance with the works and lives of other men and other
peoples opened before him. He does not always reveal the possession of
that high quality of genius which is able to interpret the most various
forces and to discover the higher principles of unity which alone make
them intelligible; indeed, he often loses himself completely in a
wilderness of thoughts and notions which have come to him from other
men and other ages, and the result is dire confusion.
We shall be disappointed, too,
if we seek in the works of Eusebius for evidences of a refined literary
taste, or for any of the charms which attach to the writings of a great
master of composition. His style is, as a rule, involved and obscure,
often painfully rambling and incoherent. This quality is due in large
part to the desultoriness of his thinking. He did not often enough
clearly define and draw the boundaries of his subject before beginning
to write upon it. He apparently did much of his thinking after he had
taken pen in hand, and did not subject what he had thus produced to a
sufficiently careful revision, if to any revision at all. Thoughts and
suggestions poured in upon him while he was writing; and he was not
always able to resist the temptation to insert them as they came, often
to the utter perversion of his train of thought, and to the ruin of the
coherency and perspicuity of his style. It must be acknowledged, too,
that his literary taste was, on the whole, decidedly vicious. Whenever
a flight of eloquence is attempted by him, as it is altogether too
often, his style becomes hopelessly turgid and pretentious. At such
times his skill in mixing metaphors is something astounding (compare,
for instance,
H. E
. II. 14). On the other hand, his works
contain not a few passages of real beauty. This is especially true of
his
Martyrs of Palestine
, where his enthusiastic admiration for
and deep sympathy with the heroes of the faith cause him often to
forget himself and to describe their sufferings in language of genuine
fire or pathos. At times, too, when he has a sharply defined and
absorbing aim in mind, and when the subject with which he is dealing
does not seem to him to demand rhetorical adornment, he is simple and
direct enough in his language, showing in such cases that his commonly
defective style is not so much the consequence of an inadequate command
of the Greek tongue as of desultory thinking and vicious literary
taste.
But while we find much to
criticise in Eusebius’ writings, we ought not to fail to give him
due credit for the conscientiousness and faithfulness with which he did
his work. He wrote often, it is true, too rapidly for the good of his
style, and he did not always revise his works as carefully as he should
have done; but we seldom detect undue haste in the collection of
materials or carelessness and negligence in the use of them. He seems
to have felt constantly the responsibilities which rested upon him as a
scholar and writer, and to have done his best to meet those
responsibilities. It is impossible to avoid contrasting him in this
respect with the most learned man of the ancient Latin Church, St.
Jerome. The haste and carelessness with which the latter composed his
De Viris Illustribus
, and with which he translated and continued
Eusebius’
Chronicle
, remain an everlasting disgrace to
him. An examination of those and of some others of Jerome’s works
must tend to raise Eusebius greatly in our esteem. He was at least
conscientious and honest in his work, and never allowed himself to palm
off ignorance as knowledge, or to deceive his readers by sophistries,
misstatements, and pure inventions. He aimed to put the reader into
possession of the knowledge which he had himself acquired, but was
always conscientious enough to stop there, and not attempt to make
fancy play the
rôle
of fact.
One other point, which was
mentioned some pages back, and to which Lightfoot calls particular
attention, should be referred to here, because of its bearing upon the
character of Eusebius’ writings. He was, above all things, an
apologist; and the apologetic aim governed both the selection of his
subjects and method of his treatment. He composed none of his works
with a
purely scientific aim. He thought always of the practical result
to be attained, and his selection of material and his choice of method
were governed by that. And yet we must recognize the fact that this aim
was never narrowing in its effects. He took a broad view of
apologetics, and in his lofty conception of the Christian religion he
believed that every field of knowledge might be laid under tribute to
it. He was bold enough to be confident that history, philosophy, and
science all contribute to our understanding and appreciation of divine
truth; and so history and philosophy and science were studied and
handled by him freely and fearlessly. He did not feel the need of
distorting truth of any kind because it might work injury to the
religion which he professed. On the contrary, he had a sublime faith
which led him to believe that all truth must have its place and its
mission, and that the cause of Christianity will be benefited by its
discovery and diffusion. As an apologist, therefore, all fields of
knowledge had an interest for him; and he was saved that pettiness of
mind and narrowness of outlook which are sometimes characteristic of
those who write with a purely practical motive.