SECT. II
Some plain consequences of the foregoing concessions.
If it be as Mr. W. says, that the church ought to admit none to their holy communion,
493
in special ordinances, but visible saints, and that this visibility must be such as to a judgment
of rational charity, makes them appear as real saints, and those that are admitted must be
such as profess real saintship, gospel-holiness, in distinction from moral sincerity; then the
whole of my first argument, from the nature of a visibility and profession of Christianity, is
allowed by him, in both premises and consequences. And indeed Mr. W. does not only do
thus consequentially, but he is express in it. In (p. 4. c.) taking notice of this argument, he
says, ’‘The sense and force of it wholly lies in this compass; a visible saint is one that to the
view, appearance, and judgment of the church, is a real saint; and since none but visible
saints are to be admitted by the church, therefore none are to be admitted but such as appear
to the view and judgment of the church to be real saints.“ But these things, which Mr. W.
himself allows as the sum of the argument, both premises and consequence, are expressly
allowed by him in what there follows.
2. If there must be a visibility and profession of real piety, in distinction from moral
sincerity, so that it can be truly said, as Mr. W. says with discretive terms, and notes of dis-
crimination, that not merely the one must be professed, but the other; and that more than
moral sincerity must be professed, &c.—Then it follows (or rather it is the same thing) that
men must profess religion with some discrimination, or marks of difference in their words,
distinguishing what is professed from moral sincerity; contrary to what Mr. W. strenuously
and frequently asserts, (p. 6. c. d. and p. 9. c. and many other places.) For if the profession
is made in words that signify no difference, then nothing different is signified or professed
by those words; and so nothing MORE; contrary to what Mr. W. also asserts
3. If it be as Mr. W. says, that the Scripture has determined none ought to be admitted,
but such as make an open profession and declaration of a hearty consent to the terms of the
covenant of grace, such as covenant with God with their whole hearts, and profess gospel-
holiness: then the whole of my second argument, concerning explicit covenanting with God,
is expressly allowed, in both premises and consequence; though Mr. W. seems at the same
time, with much labour and earnestness, to militate against it. For the premises are, that all
outfit openly and explicitly to own God’s covenant, or consent to the terms of it. This is the
same thing that he asserts, as above. And the consequence, or thing which I inferred from
it, was, that all that are admitted ought to make a profession of real godliness: and this also
he expressly and often allows.
4. Since it is supposed, that in order to admission, men ought to profess real friendship
to Christ, and love to him above the world, and to profess a proper respect to Christ in their
hearts, as well as true notion of him in their heads; and that they ought to profess gospel-
holiness, and not merely moral sincerity: therefore the whole of what belongs to my third
SECTION II. Consequences.
1918
SECTION II. Consequences.