Canon XVIII.
The crime of conspiracy or banding together is utterly prohibited even by the secular
law, and much more ought it to be forbidden in the Church of God. Therefore, if any,
whether clergymen or monks, should be detected in conspiring or banding together, or
hatching plots against their bishops or fellow-clergy, they shall by all means be deposed
from their own rank.
Notes.
Ancient Epitome of Canon XVIII.
Clerics and Monks, if they shall have dared to hold conventicles and to conspire against
the bishop, shall be cast out of their rank.
Bright.
In order to appreciate this canon, we must consider the case of Ibas bishop of Edessa.
He had been attached to the Nestorians, but after the reunion between Cyril and John of
Antioch had re-entered into communion with Cyril on the ground that Cyril had explained
his anathemas (Mansi, vii., 240), or, as he wrote to Maris (in a letter famous as one of the
“Three Chapters”) that God had “softened the Egyptian’s heart” (ib., 248). Four of his priests
(Samuel, Cyrus, Maras, and Eulegius), stimulated, says Fleury (xxvij. 19) by Uranius bishop
of Himeria, accused Ibas of Nestorianism before his patriarch Domnus of Antioch, who
held a synod, but, as Samuel and Cyrus failed to appear, pronounced them defaulters and
set aside the case (Mansi, vii. 217). They went up to Constantinople, and persuaded
Theodosius and archbishop Flavian to appoint a commission for inquiring into the matter.
Two sessions, so to speak, were held by the three prelates thus appointed, one at Berytus
the other at Tyre. At Berytus, according to the extant minutes (Mansi, vii., 212 ff.), five new
accusers joined the original four, and charges were brought which affected the moral char-
acter of Ibas as well as his orthodoxy. The charge of having used a “blasphemous” speech
implying that Christ was but a man deified, was rebutted by a statement signed by some
sixty clerics of Edessa, who according to the accusers, had been present when Ibas uttered
it. At Tyre the episcopal judges succeeded in making peace, and accusers and accused partook
of the communion together (ib., vii., 209). The sequence of these proceedings cannot be
thoroughly ascertained, but Hefele (sect. 169) agrees with Tillemont (xv., 474 et seqq.) in
dating the trial at Berytus slightly earlier than that at Tyre, and assigning both to the February
of 448 or 449. Fleury inverts this order, and thinks that, “notwithstanding the reconciliation”
at Tyre, the four accusers renewed their prosecution of Ibas (xxvij. 20); but he has to suppose
two applications on their part to Theodosius and Flavian, which seems improbable. “The
Council is believed,” says Tillemont (xv., 698), “to have had this case in mind when drawing
up the present canon:” and one can hardly help thinking that, on a spot within sight of
Constantinople, they must have recalled the protracted sufferings which malignant plotters
had inflicted on St. Chrysostom.
Canon XVIII.
520
Canon XVIII.