THE PERPETUAL VIRGINITY OF BLESSED MARY.
see you have a reason for your silence. Let
me point out then what John says, ' " But there were standing by the cross of Jesus his
mother, and his mother's sister, Mary the wife
of Clopas, and Mary Magdalene." No one doubts that there were two apostles called by
the name James, James the son of Zebedee,
and James the son of Alphseus. Do you in-
tend the comparatively unknown James the
less, who is called in Scripture the son of
Mary, not however of Mary the mother of
our Lord, to be an apostle, or not ? If he is
an apostle, he must be the son of Alphseus
and a believer in Jesus, " For neither did his
brethren believe in him." If he is not an apostle, but a third James (who he can be
I cannot tell), how can he be regarded as
the Lord's brother, and how, being a third, can he be called less to distinguish him from
greater, when greater and less are used to de-
note the relations existing, not between three,
but between two ? Notice, moreover, that the
Lord's brother is an apostle, since Paul says,"
" Then after three years I went up to Jerusa- lem to visit Cephas, and tarried with him fif-
teen days. But other of the Apostles saw I
none, save James the Lord's brother." And in
the same Epistle,* "And when they perceived the grace that was given unto me, James and
Cephas and John, who were reputed to be
pillars," etc. And that you may not suppose this James to be the son of Zebedee, you have
only to read the Acts of the Apostles, and
you will find that the latter had already been
slain by Herod. The only conclusion is that
the Mary who is described as the mother of
James the less was the wife of Alphaeus and
sister of Mary the Lord's mother, the one who
is called by John the Evangelist " Mary of
Clopas," whether after her father, or kindred, or for some other reason. But if you think
they are two persons because elsewhere we read,
'• Mary the mother of James the less," and here,
" Mary of Clopas," you have still to learn that it is customary in Scripture for the same
individual to bear different names. Raguel,
Moses' father-in-law, is also called Jethro.
L Gecleon,4 without any apparent reason for the I change, all at once becomes Jerubbaal. Ozias,
I king of Judah, has an alternative, Azarias.
Mount Tabor is called Itabyrium. Again
Hermon is called by the Phenicians Sanior,
!• and by the Amorites Sanir. The same tract
I of country is known by three names,1 Negebh, Teman, and Darom in Ezekiel. Peter is also
I called Simon and Cephas. Judas the zealot
!' S. John xix. 25. » Gal. i. 18, iq. ' Gal. ii. 9. « But see Judges vi. 2.
'The \\vto.Negtbk signifies South, and it is probable that the land of Teman was a southern portion of the land of Edom.
If Darom be the right reading, it is, apparently, the same as Dedan (Ezek. xxv. 13, etci.
in another Gospel is called Thaddaeus. And
there are numerous other examples which the reader will be able to collect for himself from
every part of Scripture.
1 6. Now here we have the explanation of
what I am endeavouring to show, how it is that
the sons of Mary, the sister of our Lord's mother, who though not formerly believers
afterwards did believe, can be called brethren
of the Lord. Possibly the case might be that
one of the brethren believed immediately
while the others did not believe until long
after, and that one Mary was the mother of
James and Joses, namely, " Mary of Clopas," who is the same as the wife of Alphseus, the
other, the mother of James the less. In any
case, if she (the latter) had been the Lord's mother S. John would have allowed her the title,
as everywhere else, and would not by calling
her the mother of other sons have given a
wrong impression. But at this stage I do not
wish to argue for or against the supposition
that Mary the wife of Clopas and Mary the
mother of James and Joses were different
women, provided it is clearly understood that
Mary the mother of James and Joses was not
the same person as the Lord's mother. How then, says Helvidius, do you make out that they
were called the Lord's brethren who were not his
brethren ? I will show how that is. In Holy
Scripture there are four kinds of brethren — by nature, race, kindred, love. Instances of
brethren by nature are Esau and Jacob, the
twelve patriarchs, Andrew and Peter, James
and John. As to race, all Jews are called
brethren of one another, as in Deuteronomy,
1 " If thy brother, an Hebrew man, or an Hebrew woman, be sold unto thee, and serve
thee six years ; then in the seventh year thou
shalt let him go free from thee." And in the
same book/ " Thou shalt in anywise set him king over thee, whom the Lord thy God shall
choose : one from among thy brethren shalt
thou set king over thee ; thou mayest not put
a foreigner over thee, which is not thy brother."
And again,3 " Thou shalt not see thy brother's ox or his sheep go astray, and hide thyself
from them': thou shalt surely bring them again unto thy brother. And if thy brother
be not nigh unto thee, or if thou know him
not, then thou shalt bring it home to thine
house, and it shall be with thee until thy
brother seek after it, and thou shalt restore it
to him again." And the Apostle Paul says,
1 " I could wish that I myself were anathema
from Christ for my brethren's sake, my kins- men according to the flesh : who are Israel-
ites. " Moreover they are called brethren by kindred who are of one family, that is
1 Deut. xv. 12.
3 Deut. xxii. i.
2 Deut. xvii. 15. « Rom. ix. 3, 4.