6.
The Present
Translation
.
1.
Text.
It was proposed
at first to make the translation from the text of Herding. This, and
all editions, gave so little basis for scientific certainty in regard
to various readings that a cursory examination of
mss.
was made. At the suggestion of Professor O. von
Gebhardt of Berlin the examination was made as thorough and systematic
as possible with definite reference to a new edition. The translator
hoped to finish and publish the new text before the translation was
needed for this series, but classification of the
mss.
proved unexpectedly intricate and the question of the
Greek translation so difficult that publication has been delayed. The
material has however been gathered, analyzed, sifted and arranged
sufficiently to give reasonable certainty as to the body of the work
and a tolerably reliable judgment on most of the important
variations.
While anxious not to claim too
much for his material and unwilling to give a final expression of
judgment on disputed readings, until his table of
mss.
is perfected, he ventures to think that for
substantial purposes of translation, if not for the nicer ones of a new
text, the material and method which he has made use of will be
substantially conclusive.
The following translation has
been made first from the text of Herding and then corrected from the
manuscripts in all places where the evidence was clearly against the
edition. In places where the evidence is fairly conclusive the change
has been made and a brief statement of evidence given in the notes.
When the evidence is really doubtful the reading has been allowed to
stand with evidence generally given.
The materials of evidence used
are 1. eight
mss.
collated entire by the
translator A. Parisinus (Corbeiensis or Sangermanensis 7 cent.) T.
Vaticanus Reg., 7 cent.; 25 Veronensis, 8 cent.; 30 Vercellensis 8
cent.; 31 Monspessalanensis 8 or 9 cent.; a Monacensis 8 cent.; e
Vindobonensis 8 or 9; H. Parisinus 10 or 9.
2. Occasional support from
readings gathered by him from other
mss.
,
chiefly 10 Cassenatensis 9 cent.; 21 Florentinus, 11 cent.; 32
Toletanus 13 cent.; 40 Guelferbyrtinus, 10? cent.
3. Readings from
mss.
mentioned by other editors.
4. The various editions, but
mainly confined to Vallarsi and Herding in Jerome, Fabricius and
Herding in Gennadius.
The translator has examined
nearly 90
mss.
and secured more or less
readings from nearly all with reference to an exact table. The readings
of several are extensive enough to have pretty nearly the value of full
collations. Quotations are occasionally made from these (e.g. from 10,
21, 29, 32, 40, etc.) but practically quotations from the eight
mentioned
mss.
cover the evidence and without
a table more would rather obscure than otherwise.
There is no opportunity here to
discuss the relative value of these used. It may be said however that
they are the oldest
mss.
, and include pretty
much all the oldest. Though age itself is by no means conclusive, the
fact that they certainly represent several independent groups makes it
safe to say that a consensus of seven against one or even six against
any two (with certain reservations) or in the case of Gennadius of 5
against 2 is conclusive for a reading. As a matter of fact against many
readings of Herding and even of Vallarsi,
are arranged all these
mss.
, and against some nearly all or even every ms.
seen, e.g. Her. p. 73 d. 12 reads morti dari with Migne-Fabricius but
all these
mss.
have mutandam and so 91. 22
“seven” for “eight.” On p. 161. 7. Her. omits
Asyncritus against
mss.
and all modern eds.,
so 44. 3. “Ponti,” 51. 7 “ut quidem putant;”
77. 25. “firmare” and a score of other places.
Of course this is not enough
evidence or discussion for a critical scholastic text but for the
practical illustrative purpose in hand will serve. Any evidence which
does not give a well digested genealogy of
mss.
and the evidence for their classification must be
reckoned as incomplete,—all that the above evidence can claim to
do, is to give the translator’s judgment respecting the readings
and
illustrative
evidence, but it is not probable that the
completed table will alter many (if any) of these readings which are
given in view of a tentative table which will likely prove
final.
The Translation
itself.
The plan of this work includes (a)
a translation, in which the translator has tried to give a fair
representation of the text in a not too ragged form but has failed to
improve on the original. The works were written as science rather than
literature and have many facts but no style. The translator has
therefore aimed rather at representing these facts than at producing a
piece of polite literature. (b) Notes are subjoined including, first
the brief biographical data which every one wants first to orient
himself by, secondly textual notes, and thirdly, occasional explanatory
notes.