PART I.
the question stated and explained.
The main question I would consider, and for the negative of which I would offer some arguments in the following discourse is this;
Whether, according to the rules of
christ
, any ought to be admitted to the communion and privileges of members of the visible church of
christ
in complete standing, but such as are in profession, and in the eye of the church’s christian judgment, godly or gracious persons
?
When I speak of members of the visible church of christ,
in complete standing,
I would be understood of those who are received as the proper immediate subjects of all the external privileges Christ has appointed for the ordinary members of his church. I say
ordinary members,
in distinction from any peculiar privileges and honours of church-officers and rulers. All allow, there are some that are in some respect in the church of God, who are not members in
complete standing, in the sense that has been explained. All that acknowledge infant baptism, allow infants, who are the proper subjects of baptism, and are baptized, to be in some sort members of the christian church; yet none suppose them to be members in such standing as to be the proper immediate subjects of all ecclesiastical ordinances and privileges: but that some further qualifications are requisite in order to this, to be obtained, either in a course of nature, or by education, or by
divine grace. And some who are baptized in infancy, even after they come to be adult, may yet remain for a season short of such a standing as has been spoken of; being destitute of sufficient knowledge, and perhaps some other qualifications, through the neglect of parents, or their own negligence, or otherwise; or because they carelessly neglected to qualify themselves for ecclesiastical privileges by making a public profession of the christian faith, or owning the christian covenant, or
forbear to offer themselves as candidates for these privileges; and yet not be cast out of the church, or cease to be in any respect its members: this, I suppose, will also be generally allowed.
One thing mainly intended in the foregoing question is, whether any adult persons but such as are in the profession and appearance endowed with the christian grace or piety, ought to be admitted to
the
christian sacraments
. Particularly, whether they ought to be admitted to the
Lord’s supper
; and, if they are such as were not baptized in infancy, ought to be admitted to
baptism
. Adult persons having those qualifications that oblige
others to receive them as the proper immediate subjects of the christian sacraments, is a main thing intended in the question, by being such as
ought to be admitted to the communion and privileges of members of the visible church, in complete standing
. There are many adult persons that by the allowance of all are in some respects within the church of God, who are not members in good standing, in this respect. There are many, for instance, that have not at present the qualifications
proper to recommend them to the
Lord’s supper
: there are many scandalous persons, who are under suspension. The late venerable
Mr. Stoddard,
and many other great divines, suppose, that even excommunicated persons are still members of the church of God; and some suppose, the worshippers of Baal in Israel, even those who were bred up such from their infancy, remained still members of the church of God. And very many protestant divines suppose, that the members of the church of Rome,
though they are brought up and live continually in gross idolatry, and innumerable errors and superstitions that tend utterly to make void the gospel of Christ, still are in the visible church of Christ: yet, I suppose, no orthodox divines would hold these to be properly and regularly qualified for the Lord’s supper. It was therefore requisite, in the question before us, that a distinction should be made between the members of the visible church
in general,
and members
in complete
standing
.
It was also requisite, that such a distinction should be made in the question, to avoid lengthening out this discourse exceedingly, with needless questions and debates concerning the state of baptized infants; that is
needless
as to my present purpose. Though I have no doubts about the doctrine of infant baptism; yet God’s manner of dealing with such infants as are regularly dedicated to him in baptism, is a matter liable to great disputes and many controversies,
and would require a large dissertation by itself to clear it up; which, as it would extend this discourse beyond all bounds, so it appears not necessary in order to a clear determination of the present question. The revelation of God’s word is much plainer and more express concerning adult persons, that act for themselves in religious matters, than concerning infants. The Scriptures were written for the sake of adult persons, or those that are capable of knowing what is written. It is to such
the apostle speaks in the Epistles, and to such only does God speak throughout his word; and the Scriptures especially speak for the sake of these, and about those to
whom
they speak. And therefore if the word of God affords us light enough concerning those spoken of in the question, as I have stated it, clearly to determine the matter with respect to them, we need not wait till we see all doubts and controversies about baptized infants cleared and settled, before we pass a judgment with
respect to the point in hand. The denominations, characters, and descriptions, which we find given in the Scripture to visible Christians, and to the visible church, are principally with an eye to the church of Christ in its adult state and proper standing. If any one was about to describe that kind of birds called doves, it would be most proper to describe grown doves, and not young ones in the egg or nest, without wings or feathers. So if any one should describe a palm-tree or olive-tree by
their visible form and appearance, it would be presumed that they described those of these kinds of trees in their natural and proper state; and not as just peeping from the ground, or as thunder-struck or blown down. And therefore I would here give notice, once for all, that when in the ensuing discourse I use such like phrases as
visible saints,
members of the visible church,
&c. I, for the most part, mean persons that are
adult
and in
good
standing
.
The question is not, whether Christ has made converting grace or piety
itself
the condition or rule of his people’s admitting any to the privileges of members in full communion with them. There is no one qualification of the
mind
whatsoever, that Christ has properly made the term of this; not so much as a common belief that
Jesus
is the
Messiah,
or a belief of the being of a God. It is the credible
profession
and
visibility
of
these things, that
is the church’s rule in this case. Christian
piety
or godliness may be a qualification requisite to communion in the christian sacraments, just in the same manner as a
belief
that Jesus is the Messiah, and the Scriptures the word of God, are requisite qualifications; and in the same manner as some kind of
repentance
is a qualification in one that has been suspended for being grossly scandalous, in order to his coming again to the Lord’s
supper; and yet godliness
itself
not be properly the rule of the church’s proceeding, in like manner as such a belief and repentance, as I have mentioned, are not their rule. It is a
visibility
to the eye of a christian judgment, that is the rule of the church’s proceeding in each of these cases.–There are two
distinctions
must be here observed. As,
1. We must distinguish between such qualifications as are requisite to give a person a right to ecclesiastical privileges in
foro
ecclesiæ,
or a right to be admitted by the
church
to those privileges; and those qualifications that are a proper and good foundation for a man’s
own
conduct in coming and offering himself as a candidate for immediate admission to these privileges. There is a difference between these. Thus, for instance, a
profession
of the belief of a future state and of revealed religion, and some other things that are internal and out of sight, and a visibility of these things to the eye of a christian judgment, is all relating to these things, that is requisite to give a man a right in
foro ecclesiæ,
or before the church; but it is the real existence of these things, that is what lays a proper and
good
foundation for his making this profession, and so demanding these privileges. None will
suppose, that he has good and proper ground for such a conduct, who does not believe another world, nor believe the Bible to be the word of God. And then,
2. We must distinguish between that which
nextly
brings an obligation on a man’s conscience to seek admission to a christian ordinance, and that which is a good foundation for the dictate of an enlightened well-informed conscience, and so in properly a
solid
foundation of a right in him to act thus. Certainly this distinction does really take place among mankind in innumerable cases. The dictates of men’s consciences are what bring them under a most
immediate
obligation to act; but it is that which is a good foundation for such a dictate of an
enlightened
conscience, that alone is a
solid
foundation of a right in him so to act. Believing the doctrine of the Trinity
with all the heart,
in some sense, (let us suppose a moral sense,) is one thing requisite in order to a person’s having a solid foundation of a right in him to go and demand baptism in the name of the Trinity; but his
best
judgment
or
dictate of his conscience, concerning his believing this doctrine with this sincerity, or with all his heart, may be sufficient to bring an obligation on his conscience. Again, when a delinquent has been convicted of scandal, it is repentance in some respect sincere, (some moral sincerity,) that is a proper foundation of a right in him to offer himself for forgiveness and restoration; but it is the dictate of his conscience or his
best judgment
concerning his sincerity, that is the thing
which immediately obliges him to offer himself. It is repentance
itself,
that is the proper qualification fundamental of his right, and without which he cannot have a proper right; for though he may be deceived, and think he has real repentance when he has not, yet he has not properly a right to be deceived; and perhaps deceit in such cases is always owing to something blamable, or the influence of some corrupt principle: but yet his best judgment brings him under obligation. In the same
manner, and no otherwise, I suppose that christian
grace itself
is a qualification requisite in order to a proper solid ground of a right in a person to come to the christian sacraments. But of this I may say something more when I come to answer objections.
When I speak, in the question, of being godly or gracious in the eye of a christian judgment, by
christian judgment
I intend something further than a kind of mere
negative
charity, implying that we forbear to censure and condemn a man, because we do not know but that he may be godly, and therefore forbear to proceed on the foot of such a censure or judgment in our treatment of him: as we would kindly entertain a stranger, not knowing but in so doing we
entertain an angel or precious saint of God. But I mean a
positive judgment,
founded on some positive appearance, or visibly, some outward manifestations that ordinarily render the thing probable. There is a difference between suspending our judgment, or forbearing to condemn, or having some hope that
possibly
the thing may be so, and so hoping the best; and a positive judgment in favour of a person. For having some hope, only implies that a man is not in utter despair of a thing,
though his prevailing opinion may be otherwise, or he may suspend his opinion. Though we cannot know a man believes that
Jesus
is the
Messiah,
yet we expect some positive manifestation or visibility of it, to be a ground of our charitable judgment: so I suppose the case is here.
When I speak of christian
judgment,
I mean a judgment wherein men do properly exercise reason, and have their reason under the due influence of love and other christian principles; which do not blind reason, but regulate its exercises; being not contrary to reason, though they be very contrary to censoriousness, or unreasonable niceness and rigidness.
I say
in the eye of the
Church’s
christian judgment,
because it is properly a visibility to the eye of the public charity, and not of a private judgment, that gives a person a right to be received as a visible saint by the public. If any are known to be persons of an honest character, and appear to be of good understanding in the doctrines of Christianity, and particularly those doctrines that teach the grand condition of salvation, and the nature of true
saving religion, and publicly and seriously profess the great and main things wherein the essence of true religion or godliness consists, and their conversation is agreeable; this justly recommends them to the good opinion of the public, whatever suspicions and fears any particular person, either the minister, or some other, may entertain, from what he in particular has observed, perhaps from the manner of his expressing himself in giving an account of his experiences, or an obscurity in the
order and method of his experiences, &c. The minister in receiving him to the communion of the church, is to act as a public officer, and in behalf of the public society, and not merely for himself, and therefore is to be governed, in acting, by a proper visibility of godliness in the eye of the public.
It is not my design, in holding the negative of the foregoing question, to affirm, that all who are regularly admitted as members of the visible church in complete standing, ought to be believed to be godly or gracious persons, when taken
collectively,
or considered in the gross, by the judgment of any person or society. This may not be, and yet each person taken singly may visibly be a gracious person to the eye of the judgment of Christians in general. These two
are not the same thing, but vastly diverse; and the latter maybe, and yet not the former. If we should know so much of a thousand persons one after another, and from what we observed in them should have a prevailing opinion concerning each one of them, singly taken, that they were indeed pious, and think the judgment we passed, when we consider each judgment apart, to be right; it will not follow, when we consider the whole company collectively, that we shall have so high an opinion of our own
judgment, as to think it probable, there was not one erroneous judgment in the whole thousand. We all have innumerable judgments about one thing or other, concerning religious, moral, secular, and philosophical affairs, concerning past, present, and future matters, reports, facts, persons, things, &c. And concerning all the many thousand dictates of judgment that we have, we think them every one right, taken singly; for if there was any one that we thought wrong, it would not be our
judgment; and yet there is no man, unless he is stupidly foolish, who when he considers all in the gross, will say he thinks that his every opinion he is of, concerning all persons and things whatsoever, important and trifling, is right, without the least error. But the more clearly to illustrate this matter, as it related to visibility, or probable appearances of holiness in professors: supposing it had been found by experience concerning precious stones, that such and such external marks were
probable
signs of a diamond; and supposing, by putting together a great number of experiments, the probability is
as ten to one,
that, take one time with another,
one in ten
of the stones which have these marks (and no visible signs to the contrary) proves to be not a true diamond. Then it will follow, that when I find a particular stone with these marks, and nothing to the contrary, there is a probability of
ten to one,
concerning that stone, that it is
a diamond; and so concerning each stone that I find with these marks: but if we take
ten
of these together, it is as probable as not, that some
one
of the ten is spurious; because, if it were not as likely as not, that
one to ten
is false, or if taking
one ten
with another, there were not
one in ten
that was false, then the probability of those, that have these marks, being true diamonds, would be more than
ten to one,
contrary to the supposition;
because that is what we mean by a probability of
ten to one,
that they are not false,
viz.
that take one
ten
with another there will be
one
false stone among them, and no more. Hence if we take a
hundred
such stones together, the probability will be just
ten to one,
that there is
one
false among them; and as likely as not that there are
ten
false ones in the whole hundred. And the probability of the individuals must be much greater than
ten
to one, even a probability of more than a
hundred
to one in order to its making it probable that every one is true. It is an easy mathematical demonstration. Hence the negative of the foregoing question by no means implies a pretence of any scheme, that shall be effectual to keep all hypocrites out of the church, and for the establishing in that sense a
pure church
.
When it is said, those who are admitted, &c. ought to be by profession
godly
or
gracious
persons; it is not meant, they should merely
profess
or
say
that they are converted or are gracious persons, that they
know
so, or
think
so; but that they profess the great things wherein christian piety consists,
viz.
a supreme respect to God, faith in Christ, &c. Indeed it is necessary, as men would keep a good conscience,
that they should think that these things are in them, which they profess to be in them; otherwise they are guilty of the horrid wickedness of willfully making a lying profession. Hence it is supposed to be necessary, in order to men’s regularly and with a good conscience coming into communion with the church of Christ in the christian sacraments, that they themselves should suppose the essential things, belonging to christian piety, to be in them.
It does not belong to the present question, to consider and determine what the nature of christian piety is, or wherein it consists: this question may be properly determined, and the determination demonstrated, without entering into any controversies about the nature of conversion, &c. Nor does an asserting the negative of the question determine any thing how particular the profession of godliness ought to be, but only that the more essential things, which belong to
it, ought to be professed. Nor is it determined, but that the public professions made on occasion of persons’ admission to the Lord’s supper, in some of our churches, who yet go upon that principle, that persons need not esteem themselves truly gracious in order to a coming conscientiously and properly to the Lord’s supper; I say, it is not determined but that some of these professions are sufficient, if those that made them were taught to use the words, and others to understand them, in no
other than their proper meaning, and principle and custom had not established a meaning very diverse from it, or perhaps an use of the words without any distinct and clear determinate meaning.