eternal ignorance; or if they did know, the darkness of eternal fear. Thus part of the substance
of your god really did remain from eternity in its own darkness; and instead of admiring
new light on its appearance, it only met with another and a hostile darkness, of which it had
always been in fear. Indeed, God himself must have been in the darkness of fear for this
part of himself, if he was dreading the evil coming upon it. If he did not foresee the evil, he
must have been in the darkness of ignorance. If he foresaw it, and was not in fear, the
darkness of such cruelty is worse than the darkness either of ignorance or of fear. Your god
appears to be destitute of the quality which the apostle commends in the body, which you
insanely believe to be made not by God, but by Hyle: "If one member suffers, all the members
suffer with it."828 But suppose he did suffer; he foresaw, he feared, he suffered, but he could
not help himself. Thus he remained from eternity in the darkness of his own misery; and
then, instead of admiring a new light which was to drive away the darkness, he came in
contact, to the injury of his own light, with another darkness which he had always dreaded.
Again, would it not have been much better, I say, not to have given a commandment like
God, but even to have received a commandment like Adam, which he would be rewarded
for keeping and punished for breaking, acting either way by his own free-will, than to be
forced by inevitable necessity to admit darkness into his light in spite of himself? Surely it
would have been better to have given a precept to human nature, not knowing that it would
become sinful, than to have been driven by necessity to sin contrary to his own divine nature.
Think for a moment, and say how darkness could be conquered by one who was himself
conquered by necessity. Conquered already by this greater enemy, he fought under his
conqueror’s orders against a less formidable opponent. Would it not have been better not
to know where Adam had hid himself, than to have been himself destitute of any means of
escape, first from a hard and hateful necessity, and then from a dissimilar and hostile race?
Would it not have been better to grudge eternal life to human nature, than to consign to
misery the divine nature; to desire the blood and fat of sacrifices, than to be himself
slaughtered in so many forms, on account of his mixture with the blood and fat of every
victim; to be disturbed by jealousy at these sacrifices being offered to other gods as well as
to himself, than to be himself offered on all altars to all devils, as mixed up not only with all
fruits, but also with all animals? Would it not have been much better to be affected even
with human anger, so as to be enraged against both his friends and his enemies for their
sins, than to be himself influenced by fear as well as by anger wherever these passions exist,
or than to share in all the sin that is committed, and in all punishment that is suffered? For
this is the doom of that part of your god which is in confinement everywhere, condemned
to this by himself, not as guilty, but in order to conquer his dreaded enemy. Doomed himself
to such a fatal necessity, the part of himself which he has given over to condemnation might
828 1 Cor. xii. 26.
478
Faustus states his objections to the morality of the law and the prophets,…