Beveridge, and as Balsamon had it, to the effect that: “In the same way (as the preceding)
are the Manichæans, Valentinians, Marcionites, and similar heretics to be treated (i.e., to
be baptized anew); but the Nestorians must (merely) present certificates, and anathematize
406
their heresy, Nestorius, Eutyches, etc.” Here we have only this mistake, that the Nestorians
must anathematize, among others, also Eutyches, which they would certainly have done
very willingly. At the best, we must suppose that there is a gap in the text, and that after,
“all of similar heresies,” we must add “the later heretics must present certificates and ana-
thematize Nestorius, Eutyches, etc.”
There seems but little doubt that whatever may be the truth in the matter, the early
theologians and fathers held that even though the external rite of Holy Baptism might be
validly performed by schismatics and heretics, yet that by it the person so baptized did not
receive the Holy Ghost, and this opinion was not confined to the East, but was also prevalent
in the West. Vide Rupertus, De Divinis Officiis, Lib. X., Cap. xxv.
745
Canon XCV.