Elucidations.
————————————
I.
(Soul and Spirit, cap. xv. and notes 1 and 2, p.
463.
)
Dr. Holmes, in the learned note which follows,
affords me a valuable addition to my scanty remarks on this subject in
former volumes. See (Vol. I. pp. 387, 532,) references to the great
work of Professor Delitzsch, in notes on Irenæus. In Vol. II. p.
102, I have also mentioned M. Heard’s work, on the
Tripartite
Nature of Man
. With reference to the disagreement of the learned on
this great matter, let me ask is it not less real than apparent? The
dichotomy
to which Tertullian objected, and the
trichotomy
which Dr. Holmes makes a name of “
the triple
nature
,” are terms which rather suggest a process of
“dividing asunder of soul and spirit,” and which involve an
ambiguity that confuses the inquiry. Now, while the gravest objections
may be imagined, or even demonstrated, against a process which seems to
destroy the unity and individuality of a Man, does not every theologian
accept the analytical formula of the apostle and recognize the
bodily
, the
animal
and the
spiritual
in the life
of man? If so is there not fundamental agreement as to
1 Thess. v. 23
, and difference only, relatively,
as to functions and processes, or as to the way in which truth on these
three points ought to be stated? On this subject there are good
remarks in the
Speaker’s Commentary
on the text aforesaid,
but the exhaustive work of Delitzsch deserves study.
Man’s whole nature in Christ, seems to be
sanctified by the Holy Spirit’s suffusion of man’s
spirit
; this rules and governs the
psychic
nature and
through it the
body
.
II.
(The entire work, cap. xxi. p. 474.)
He who has followed Tertullian through the mazes in
which Marcion, in spite of shifts and turnings innumerable, has been
hunted down, and defeated, must recognize the great work performed by
this author in behalf of Christian Orthodoxy. It seems to have been the
plan of Christ’s watchful care over His Church, that, in the
earliest stages of its existence the enemy should be allowed to display
his utmost malice and to bring out all his forces against Truth. Thus,
before the meeting of Church-councils the language of faith had grown
up, and clear views and precise statements of doctrine had been
committed to the idioms of human thought. But, the labours of
Tertullian are not confined to these diverse purposes. With all the
faults of his acute and forensic mind, how powerfully he illuminates
the Scriptures and glorifies them as containing the whole system of the
Faith. How rich are his quotations, and how penetrating his
conceptions of their uses. Besides all this, what an introduction he
gives us to the modes of thought which were becoming familiar in the
West,
and which were convening the
Latin tongue to new uses, and making it capable of expressing
Augustine’s mind and so of creating new domains of Learning among
the nations of Europe.
If I have treated tenderly the reputation of this great
Master, in my notes upon his Marcion, it is with a twofold purpose.
(1.) It seems to me due to truth that his name should be less
associated with his deplorable lapse than with his long and faithful
services to the Church, and (2.) that the student should thus follow
his career with a pleasure and with a confidence the lack of which
perpetually annoys us when we give the first place to the Montanist and
not to the Catholic. Let this be our spirit in accompanying him into
his fresh campaigns against “the grievous wolves” foreseen
by St. Paul with tears.
Acts
xx. 29, 30
.
But as our Author invokes a careful examination of
his “entire work,” let the student recur to Irenæus
(Vol. I. p. 352, etc.) and observe how formidable, from the beginning,
was the irreligion of Marcion. His doctrines did truly “eat like
a canker,” assailing the Scriptures by mutilations and
corruptions of the text itself. No marvel that Tertullian shows him no
quarter, though we must often regret the forensic violence of his
retort. As to the
Dualism
which, through Marcion, thus
threatened the first article of the Creed, consult the valuable remarks
of the
Encyc. Britannica
, (“Mithras”). Mithras
became known to the Romans
circa
b.c.
70, and his worship flourished under Trajan and his successors.
An able writer remarks that it was natural “Dualism should
develop itself out of primitive Zoroastrianism. The human mind
has ever been struck with a certain antagonism of which it has sought
to discover the cause. Evil seems most easily accounted for by
the supposition of an evil Person; and the continuance of an equal
struggle, without advantage to either side, seems to imply the equality
of that evil Person with the author of all good. Thus Dualism had its
birth. Many came to believe in the existence of two co-eternal and
co-equal Persons, one good and the other evil, between whom there has
been from all eternity a perpetual conflict, and between whom the same
conflict must continue to rage through all coming
time.”