380
sojourn in life, have been fierce and domineering in disposition, slaves to every kind of lust,
passionate to madness, refraining from no act even of the most desperate wickedness, robbers
and murderers, traitors to their country, and, more execrable still, patricides, mother-killers,
child-murderers, mad after unnatural intercourse; suppose such characters grow old in this
wickedness; how, some one may ask, does this harmonize with the result of our previous
investigations? If that which is taken away before its time in order that it may not continu-
ously glut itself, according to our illustration of the banquet, with Life’s indulgences, is
providentially removed from that carouse, what is the special design in so and so, who is of
that disposition, being allowed to continue his revels1572 to old age, steeping both himself
and his boon companions in the noxious fumes of his debauchery? In fine, you will ask,
wherefore does God in His Providence withdraw one from life before his character can be
perfected in evil, and leave another to grow to be such a monster that it had been better for
him if he had never been born? In answer to this we will give, to those who are inclined to
receive it favourably, a reason such as follows: viz. that oftentimes the existence of those
whose life has been a good one operates to the advantage of their offspring; and there are
hundreds of passages testifying to this in the inspired Writings, which clearly teach us that
the tender care shown by God to those who have deserved it is shared in by their successors,
and that even to have been an obstruction, in the path to wickedness, to any one who is sure
to live wickedly, is a good result1573. But seeing that our Reason in this matter has to grope
in the dark, clearly no one can complain if its conjecturing leads our mind to a variety of
conclusions. Well, then, not only one might pronounce that God, in kindness to the Founders
of some Family, withdraws a member of it who is going to live a bad life from that bad life,
but, even if there is no antecedent such as this in the case of some early deaths, it is not un-
reasonable to conjecture that they would have plunged into a vicious life with a more des-
perate vehemence than any of those who have actually become notorious for their wickedness.
That nothing happens without God we know from many sources; and, reversely, that
God’s dispensations have no element of chance and confusion in them every one will allow,
who realizes that God is Reason, and Wisdom, and Perfect Goodness, and Truth, and could
not admit of that which is not good and not consistent with His Truth1574. Whether, then,
the early deaths of infants are to be attributed to the aforesaid causes, or whether there is
some further cause of them beyond these, it befits us to acknowledge that these things happen
for the best. I have another reason also to give which I have learnt from the wisdom of an
Apostle; a reason, that is, why some of those who have been distinguished for their
1572 ἐμπαροινεῖ
1573 κεφάλαιον; lit. “a sum total:” cf. below, ἐπὶ κεφαλαί& 251· συναπτέον, “we must summarize.”
1574 The text is in confusion here: but the Latin supplies: “Nothing reasonable fails in reason; nothing wise,
in wisdom; neither virtue nor truth could admit of that which is not good,” &c.
704
On Infants' Early Deaths.