gotten, how does it happen that man is sometimes found to be stronger than it? For, by
obeying the law of God, he will often overcome every root of wickedness; and it would be
a ridiculous thing if he, who is but the production, should be found to be stronger than the
unbegotten. Moreover, whose is that law with its commandment—that commandment, I
mean, which has been given to man? Without doubt it will be acknowledged to be God’s.
And how, then, can the law be given to an alien? or who can give his commandment to an
enemy? Or, to speak of him who receives the commandment, how can he contend against
the devil? that is to say, on this supposition, how can he contend against his own creator,
as if the son, while he is a debtor to him for deeds of kindness, were to choose to inflict in-
juries on the father? Thus you but mark out the profitlessness1605 of man on this side, if
you suppose him to be contradicting by the law and commandment him who has made
him, and to be making the effort to get the better of him. Yea, we shall have to fancy the
devil himself to have gone to such an excess of folly, as not to have perceived that in making
man he made an adversary for himself, and neither to have considered what might be his
future, nor to have foreseen the actual consequence of his act; whereas even in ourselves.
who are but productions, there are at least some small gifts of knowledge, and a measure of
prudence, and a moderate degree of consideration, which is sometimes of a very trustworthy
nature. And how, then, can we believe that in the unbegotten there is not some little portion
of prudence, or consideration, or intelligence? Or how can we make the contrary supposition,
according to your assertion, namely, that he is discovered to be of the most senseless appre-
hension, and the dullest heart and in short rather like the brutes in his natural constitution?
But if the case stands thus, again, how is it that man, who is possessed of no insignificant
power in mental capacity and knowledge, could have received his substance from one who
thus is, of all beings, the most ignorant and the bluntest in apprehension? How shall any
one be rash enough to profess that man is the workmanship of an author of this character?
But, again, if man consists both of soul and of body, and not merely of body without soul,
and if the one cannot subsist apart from the other, why will you assert that these two are
antagonistic and contrary to each other? For our Lord Jesus Christ, indeed, seems to me to
have spoken of these in His parables, when He said: “No man can put new wine into old
bottles, else the bottles will break, and the wine run out.”1606 But new wine is to be put into
new bottles, as there is indeed one and the same Lord for the bottle and for the wine. For
although the substance may be different, yet by these two substances, in their due powers,
and in the maintenance of their proper mutual relations,1607 the one person of man subsists.
1605 The reading is inutilitatem. But Routh points that this is probably the translation of τὴν εὐτέλειαν, vil-
itatem, meanness.
1606 Matt. ix. 17.
1607 Dominatione et observantiæ usu.
450
Chapter XVIII.